hsmamato2
<font color=magenta>Tink in Training-Good Girl,Bad
- Joined
- Mar 28, 2005
- Messages
- 15,842
Ok, I won't flame you... I hope I don't need an asbestos suit after this!
Not insulting choices here, I know some work for some people,some don't...we all have our own choices to make!
I know this can be a hot issue, but I side with the "no thanks" on the govt involvement... In time, it has the potential for too much misuse,and if it starts with "asking" a certain amount of criteria be met, it will end somewhere, but not necessarily where we, the parents might want it to. Hence, my position on this.
And, it may be a great alternative to actually sending your kids to ps,if you don't want to,but it's not quite the same thing.
Homeschooling involves taking back resposibility(good or bad) for our kids education,and the direction our families head in. This is the big difference, if I still have to "ask" an authority figure about attendance,compliance with certain rules, standards, then you can see why there are differences.
And, you can see the drawbacks for those of us homeschooling this way to calling them the same name- then if we're all hs'ers, what's to prevent the set criteria for your curriculum you've signed up for then being forced upon the rest of us who didn't want this?
And the obvious benefits of calling distance schooling,or charter schools homeschooling as if there were no distinction- now, if one set of "homeschoolers" readily asks for and complies with this 'help', then why not all of them? And thus the creeping in of perhaps unwanted "help" into our lives ...
So while I have no problem with choosing charter or govt funded virtual schools, I really believe that it's different from homeschooling in those fundamental ways. If I was given no choice but to send the kids to ps,or distance school at home, I'd opt for the home courses too, but homeschooling is a choice that right now we're lucky enough to be able to make!
Not insulting choices here, I know some work for some people,some don't...we all have our own choices to make!
I know this can be a hot issue, but I side with the "no thanks" on the govt involvement... In time, it has the potential for too much misuse,and if it starts with "asking" a certain amount of criteria be met, it will end somewhere, but not necessarily where we, the parents might want it to. Hence, my position on this.
And, it may be a great alternative to actually sending your kids to ps,if you don't want to,but it's not quite the same thing.
Homeschooling involves taking back resposibility(good or bad) for our kids education,and the direction our families head in. This is the big difference, if I still have to "ask" an authority figure about attendance,compliance with certain rules, standards, then you can see why there are differences.
And, you can see the drawbacks for those of us homeschooling this way to calling them the same name- then if we're all hs'ers, what's to prevent the set criteria for your curriculum you've signed up for then being forced upon the rest of us who didn't want this?
And the obvious benefits of calling distance schooling,or charter schools homeschooling as if there were no distinction- now, if one set of "homeschoolers" readily asks for and complies with this 'help', then why not all of them? And thus the creeping in of perhaps unwanted "help" into our lives ...
So while I have no problem with choosing charter or govt funded virtual schools, I really believe that it's different from homeschooling in those fundamental ways. If I was given no choice but to send the kids to ps,or distance school at home, I'd opt for the home courses too, but homeschooling is a choice that right now we're lucky enough to be able to make!

