We went back in 2004 for DH's 50th birthday. We were not impressed. The service was terrible; the food medicore and my DH hated the grapefruit cake (and he is a big dessert lover). We usually give each place two tries in case it was an "off" night, but we have never gone back. We are on the dining plan and just don't think we want to waste two table service credits per person on it when there are so many other places that we really enjoy eating at.