Kathy-your post really made me laugh.

. Especially the part about 3 kids and romance.....too funny and so true. Well, your discussion was so compelling now I don't know what to do!! $339, which is already paid for, could go towards a FEW nice massages!!! I could cancel the REAS and just book the massages and not say a word to DH. He actually wants a facial, believe it or not (my DH is so not the pampered typed - it kinda took me off guard when he told me that).
The dining rotation that is most "attractive" to me is PLA. Like you said, it would be cool to be in PC on pirate night, Lumieres on formal and AP on semi. It just fits so well and therefore keeps my compulsive planning disorder at bay HA!!! Oh, and yep, I do know they don't guarantee it but it's worth a try. I think I'm going to call
DCL today and see if they can put a request in for it for me?!
The table arrangements are already pre-set for us...we're with three other families so we'll be at one table, or so DCL told me.
I wonder why I was able to make Palo ressies last night given I'm not a CC member yet it wouldn't let me do excursions or spa ressies. Might try again today.
By the way Kathy....CAT 3!!!!!

Is that the double scoop
Castaway Cay trip? Can ya tell I'm jealous???
All kidding aside, thanks for you indepth analysis!
Liz-What are you thinking about the REAS after reading Kathy's post?