Help - Why should I be a DVC member?

petrymom

DIS Veteran
Joined
Jan 2, 2005
Messages
1,365
I need your help!!!! I returned yesterday from our first trip to Disney world! WE had an absolutely WONDERFUL Time!!! WE went on the DVC tour and at first where all for it. BUT the more I think about it the more I have my doubts. I have to decide by Tuesday to get the incentives. The initial amount isn't the issue, but I am worried about the yearly dues. What I would pay in dues for one year is what I paid for my hotel (POR) for the week. I like the idea of having Mousekeeping come in every day.

Is this club really as good a deal as they say it is? We are an average income family of four (kids 10 and 5). This was our 1st trip as a family for more than a weekend. Please help me!!!

Thanks!!!!!

Petrymom
 
There is a big difference between DVC & moderate rooms. Don't get me wrong, I love to stay in POFQ when not at DVC. However, when comparing a 1BR DVC vs. a moderate room - DVC wins hands down.
Also, DVC will encourage you to return to WDW on a regular basis. You also learn to relax and enjoy the time more because you know you will be back in the not too diatant future; a good deal, if you are a fan of the mouse!

::MickeyMo
 
Thanks for your response. I agree - when we saw the rooms - the difference was very evident. They were beautiful.

Another fear that I have is that we are pretty plain people. We visited both Saratoga Springs resort and the Beach Club resort. We didn't feel as though we fit in at either resort. High class enough??? I preferred the hominess of the Moderate resort. Would it still be worth it to join?

Petrymom
 
My family and I fit in very well at Old Key West resort. It is casual and beachy and comfortable! You and yours might fit in very well there too. They also have by far the biggest rooms, quite a bit bigger than Saratoga Springs. Hope this helps you :)
 

You'll probably get a lot of responses.

Our first trip to WDW was camping in April of 1992. I absolutely fell in love with it. My family did not travel when I was growing up. I wanted our kids to grow up with guaranteed mom and dad time every summer for two weeks. Our kids were 5 and 2 when we bought (we closed with a June use year in 1993).

My husband tells me you have to compare apples to apples. But I am really good at apples to oranges. My way of thinking just isn't like everyone elses.

If you wanted to stay in a DVC resort for 7 days; use BCV as an example because of your kids' ages. During the first two weeks of June you'd pay $4,900 (this would be cheaper probably if it didn't include Friday/Saturday night. Point wise it would be 270 (week) 150 (monday-Friday). I don't know for sure what the maintenance fees are for BCV but lets say they are 4.50 per point; that's $1,215 or $675 per year for the above stated point options.

I have to tell you that we do not use our points on weekends unless it is during the Holidays. Fridays and Saturays we usually opt out to a hotel on 192 or an Allstar for $30-60 per night. I'm an over (early) planner so I get good deals. Plus, it is a nice change of pace for the two transition days between the parks and the beach. We usually do our local shopping and meeting with friends during this time.

Up front it looks like a lot of money, once you pay your initial point costs and you are only paying maintenance fees; you can't beat what you have a available to you for the the $1,215/$675 per year.

We have never regretted our investment and that is what it is. It is an investment in your families future for spending quality time together.

Hope this helps and it wasn't too much information. Email me if you have more questions.
 
Hi! I pay my dues monthly - auto withdraw from checking and after a while I hardly noticed it. :cool1:

The vacation I get with DVC is more than I could have imagined. Our family is so close because of this. :grouphug:

As far as moderate vs. deluxe vs. home away from home... we needed a kitchen - to stay in a room big enough for 5 with a kitchen for a week would cost about $4,000. It made more sense to buy DVC since I knew we would be going back as often as we could. The kitchen saves us a lot of money.

BTW - I think you would love OKW. It's very laid back and there aren't too many snobs. :crazy:
 
Did you check out the Villas at Wilderness Lodge? It has a down to earth feel - lots of rocking chairs, hardwood floors, and an Indian southwest feel. Here's a web site with a great photo tour of the DVC resorts: tagrel.com
OKW also has a laid back great Florida feel to it. My parents felt that the BCV and BWV felt a little uppity to them. The only place they want to stay is the VWL because they feel comfortable there. I think they would like OKW too, if they ever toured it.

With 150 points you could stay from six to ten nights at VWL in low season in a studio. At OKW you could stay 13 nights in low season in a studio.

We made the decision to join because we LOVED the Wilderness Lodge and the villas was perfect for us.

Good luck with your decision. We thought about it for four months before we joined. We've been happy with our decision because we've added on to our original 150 point contract at the lodge. We now have 340 points, we added 50 more at VWL, 85 at BCV, and 55 at BWV. But, our heart belongs to the VWL first.

I actually like NOT having someone in our room everyday to clean. We like to take naps and I like not having to worry about when the maid will be there. With DVC you get trash and towel on the 4th day of your stay. They replenish toilet paper, soap, empty trash, and bring fresh towels. We hang our towels over the towel bar and reuse them after we shower if I don't want to have to do laundry. I bring colored wash cloths from home (colored so I can tell them apart from DVC's white ones). This is when we stay in a studio - DVC has free washers for DVC studio users to use, just not in the room. If you stay in a 1 bedroom or larger, then you have the washer and dryer in your room.

When we stay in a studio I usually do laundry the day before we go home (I do some of our dirty laundry and the wash cloths up). It works out great for us not having housekeeping in the room everyday.
 
I'm thinking that you're not ready yet to make that big of a decision. Not because you're not "the right kind of people" - DVC ownership really isn't a snobby kind of thing. But DVC offers specific benefits: deluxe accomodations, 'forced' regular vacations, more of a "home" feel (with W/D, DW, kitchen, etc) and less of a hotel room feel. If an occaisional trip to WDW staying at a Moderate meets your Disney needs, then DVC might be overkill for you.

I'd suggest that you not worry about the artificial "hurry-up" that the deadline gives you. Read up about DVC - and the wonderful, regular-folks type of people we are - here on the DIS. Order the planning video, and maybe even schedule a stay at a DVC resort by renting someone's points for a week or so.

Don't misunderstand - it'd be great just to wish you "Welcome Home" (and show you the secret DVC handshake) ;). But I've seen that a good understanding of what DVC does and doesn't offer is very important to being happy with a DVC purchase.

Good luck, and feel free to ask any questions!
 
I'm thinking that you're not ready yet to make that big of a decision. ;)
 
petrymom said:
I need your help!!!! I returned yesterday from our first trip to Disney world! WE had an absolutely WONDERFUL Time!!! WE went on the DVC tour and at first where all for it. BUT the more I think about it the more I have my doubts. I have to decide by Tuesday to get the incentives. The initial amount isn't the issue, but I am worried about the yearly dues. What I would pay in dues for one year is what I paid for my hotel (POR) for the week. I like the idea of having Mousekeeping come in every day.

Is this club really as good a deal as they say it is? We are an average income family of four (kids 10 and 5). This was our 1st trip as a family for more than a weekend. Please help me!!!

Thanks!!!!!

Petrymom

There is nothing one person can say here to make you decide if you want to fork out $$ to become a member and own a piece of disney for the next 42 yrs of your life. Just sit down and decide if you love disney and what it has to offer and if your planning on going there atleast every yr in half for the next 50 yrs.Remember you will now have a place to stay in the orlando area even if you want to leave the property. If you say yes and you can afford the $$ . .Then go for it. You will never be able to beat the cost in the long run of being able to stay in top resorts for so little.. IMO !!! :badpc:
 
Thanks to all of you for your input. By all means - to anyone else, please feel free to add!!!
I appreciate your honesty and DrTomorrow, you could be right. This was our first major vacation ever. Personally, I love the idea of not cooking!!!! not doing laundry!!!!! and the extra special attention that Mousekeeping gave me. I LOVED Disney, but yet, I am not sure that I am in need of the more Deluxe rooms that this club would offer.

I sounds great to say that you are a "part owner" in Disney, yet it is a rather large committment no matter how you look at it. I feel a little torn by the push to rush into the decision, but in my heart I feel I should weigh out the pros and cons of the decision.

I most certainly will be back to Disney!! That is a guarantee, but I think I will take your advise and learn from all of you first before I make the decision.

Thanks!!!!

Petrymom
 
When you plan you next vacation, visit the rent trade board and try out a DVC resort for yourself. It can be a great way to see if you like the accomodations.
 
Our family, like yours, is of moderate means and we feel right at home at BCV. We spent our first DVC vacation last Christmas (2003) and loved the experience! Like you, we don't feel comfortable among "money" but we never felt out of place at BCV. We have six children and used the 2BR and we didn't feel like we were falling over each other.

One perk that you might not have thought of is that you don't have to go to WDW every year. We go every other year and the off year, we take a small trip somewhere else using the concierage collection, world passport or the disney collection. This is our off year in 2005 and my wife and I are taking a 7-day DCL trip completely paid by DVC! It's almost a "free" vacation.

The only regret that we have involving the DVC is that we didn't do sooner when our children were smaller (our oldest is 17).

Take your time and decide. An old adage is that if it's truly a good deal now, it's a good deal a week or month from now as well.

Good luck! :wave:
 
We have been traveling to WDW for years. We stayed in the Contemporary when my dad paid for our trip, but made three trips staying at PO (Dixie Landings) and loved it. However, one year we were able to get a deal to stay at BW. We were upgraded to a one bedroom from a studio, no extra charge. We were intimidated by the valet parking, luggage service, etc. We too are simple people. We went to the presentation but didn't think we could afford it or that we wanted to commit to Disney every other year. That was the most we felt we would go.

Our last trip was in 2001, our children are now older so we needed two adjoining rooms, so double the price of the moderate resort- $300 per night. And, we had stayed at BW, been able to walk to Epcot and MGM. In other words, we were spoiled. Five years after the presentation, I called and bought 170 points, enough to go every other year, stay at BW in the summer (I am a teacher and that is the only time we can go).

I know that as we get older, it will be a place that our family can continue to vacation, when our kids get married and have kids of their own, where we can take friends, etc. I do regret not buying sooner. We were fortunate to be able to get BW in 2003 as it is now sold out.

Another of the advantages to owning DVC is the kitchen in the one and two BR. Eating a meal in once a day could easily save a family of four $300+ over a week's time. You really have a great deal of flexibility to save money.

I certainly wouldn't tell you to jump at the chance before Tuesday, but I wouldn't rule it out. There always seems to be a new incentive when the last one expires. Think about it in terms of your kids and their kids and all that it can become to you for the next 49 years.

I have realized from watching these boards that if something unforeseen occurred and I could no longer use my DCV membership, I certainly could resell it for close to what I paid for it or I could rent my points to others for much more than they cost me in my annual dues.

We are heading down for our first trip as DVC members in June. The kids, now 21 and 19 are taking friends. I was explaining this to a buddy a couple weeks ago and he asked, what is that costing you. I paused and said, it's already paid, and it is. I call it my prepaid vacation until 2042. I hope this helps. Don't feel pressured, but know that if you read these boards, you will find a common sentiment and that is regret for not buying sooner.
::MickeyMo
 
Although you may now feel that you have been talked out of buying, I will add one more thing, most of the members on this board will tell you that the only thing they regret about buying into the DVC is that they didn't buy SOONER......for whatever that is worth.....
 
TammyAlphabet said:
Although you may now feel that you have been talked out of buying, I will add one more thing, most of the members on this board will tell you that the only thing they regret about buying into the DVC is that they didn't buy SOONER......for whatever that is worth.....

::yes::
 
You might want to research everything you can about DVC before you make a final decision. Also, it would be good to figure out what type of family vacations you might plan to take in the future. Don't get me wrong, I am not trying to talk you out of buying in, but it's like any major expense, you need to be sure that it will fit your needs or you won't be happy.

We bought in after staying at YC because we knew that we would return to Disney, knew that after staying on property we would never want to stay off, and loved the location of YC, BC and BW. As it turned out they were selling BCV at the time and we decided to go for it. Like you, that year was actually our first family vacation that lasted 2 weeks (DH realized he could actually be away from work). I like an "upscale" feel because I like to be spoiled when I can, but he would be happy in a log home and yet the BCV area makes us both feel comfortable.

Our trips to WDW occur every 3 years. This year we are staying for 11 nights in a 2Br. Our contract is only 150pts, but we banked 2004, are using 2005 and are borrowing 2006 pts to get to 450. It works rather well for us. The other 2 years we travel in a pull behind camper to various locations. This year we are going to do quite a few things off property, but love the idea having a "prepaid" place to stay while in FL.

In a few years the older children will be gone and our needs will change some, but we know that we will be visiting WDW quite a few times in the future. Another thing that appeals to us is that we can use our points to vacation in other places around the world, especially when the kids are gone. On the off years that we don't go, we can rent the points and more than cover the annual dues.

We look at it as a prepaid vacation (in terms of lodging, which is a huge vacation expense). Over the long run you will save money, even after factoring in the dues, because this is paid for at today's prices and the cost of lodging will continue to go up.

Good luck in your research and decision. I wouldn't let the "sales pressure" bother you becuase you do have some time as incentives are always showing up. ::MickeyMo ::MickeyMo
 
petrymom said:
Thanks to all of you for your input. By all means - to anyone else, please feel free to add!!!
I appreciate your honesty and DrTomorrow, you could be right. This was our first major vacation ever. Personally, I love the idea of not cooking!!!! not doing laundry!!!!! and the extra special attention that Mousekeeping gave me. I LOVED Disney, but yet, I am not sure that I am in need of the more Deluxe rooms that this club would offer.

I sounds great to say that you are a "part owner" in Disney, yet it is a rather large committment no matter how you look at it. I feel a little torn by the push to rush into the decision, but in my heart I feel I should weigh out the pros and cons of the decision.

I most certainly will be back to Disney!! That is a guarantee, but I think I will take your advise and learn from all of you first before I make the decision.

Thanks!!!!

Petrymom
Never let anyone push you into making a commitment because the deal will be going away.....when I bought back in 96, Disney was a great deal, with park passes for the entire length of stay; and while I still go every year in December for the holiday magic at Disney and stay at OKW, I', not sure that the $1000+ per year for dues I'm paying wouldn't be used just as well at PO, Coronado, or one of the other mod priced places as there are few perks Disney provides to DVC members than the promise of memories and pixes dust. It's still a great place, but it's because we make it that way, not because we buy (literally) into it.
 
Another option to consider would be another timeshare company. if you like staying at WDW, maybe Starwood (Sheraton/Westin resports and hotels) would be something to look at and compare to DVC. Our friends have Starwood and can use their banked Starwood points to stay at the Swan and Dolphin if they choose. My wife and I decided on DVC, though, since we would probably be migrating to the mouse regardless :love:

Take your time, because DVC will be here for at least another 49 years! :teeth:
 
Being a DVC member sorta forces you to vacation(which isnt a bad thing).

Being in DVC allows your vacations to take on a more relaxing feel(yes, even in WDW)

Dont rush the decision because it will still be there. If time is needed, then dont hesitate to take it.

And DVC isnt an exclusive club. We are middle class. We went from staying at All Stars to DVC. I am a carpenter by trade. I put in a few extra hrs on weekends to pay for DVC. And I have no regrets. I think most DVCers are middle class folks who just enjoy WDW enough to want to spend lots of time there.
 











New Posts





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Back
Top