Originally posted by Tinkerbutt
Disneysteve...why are you not a fan of onsite? I've never had the courage to try offsite so I was looking for a different opinion!
This is a constant topic of debate around here. There are those who are firmly onsite fans and those who are just the opposite. I've done both numerous times (as my signature indicates). I think the options offsite are far better for us. I'll give a quick summary of our reasoning since this is OT for the thread. I'd be happy to go into more detail if you PM me.
1. We prefer to drive everywhere ourselves and not use Disney transport. We don't like waiting for buses and being limited to the routes they run. Why pay for a Disney hotel when we aren't going to use the transportation.
2. The rooms are small, even at the deluxe hotels. And the prices are ridiculous for what you get. Offsite we can get a 2-bedroom, 2-bath condo for as little as $55/nite, about the price of a Disney value hotel with a discount. For $79/nite, we can get a 3-bed, 2-bath house with a private screened-in pool. How can you possibly compare that to a plain room at All Stars?
3. Driving to and from the parks is really no big deal. Door to door, it only takes 10-15 minutes from the nearest developments or hotels to the parks. You could easily wait at least that long just to get a bus at a Disney hotel.
4. No matter where we stay, we always keep breakfast food on hand and eat in our room. That's much easier offsite where we have a full kitchen and full-size fridge/freezer.
5. We get 2 or more tv's so my daughter can relax and watch one show and my wife and I can watch something else.
6. When we don't share a room, we all sleep better. This alone is worth staying offsite for us. Disney is definitely one place where you need your rest to enjoy your days.
7. We still get to enjoy all that Disney has to offer. We can shop at DTD, eat at any of the onsite hotels, stop at AKL to look at the animals, watch fireworks from the Contemporary, rent a boat at the Poly, visit the petting zoo at Fort Wilderness, etc. You don't need to be a resort guest to do any of those things.
I could go on and on, but this isn't the place. Those are the main reasons, though.