Help me eliminate one restaurant

[jkp464]

We will be on DDP and need to eliminate one TS -- please help me decide which one should go: GF 1900 Park Faire (with Tremaines); Yak & Yeti; or Cap 'n Jacks.

Currently other TS we are planning are:
Coral Reef
Le Cellier
Nine Dragons
Kona Cafe
Tonys Town Square

Thanks!

 

[jenb1023]

My vote is to keep 1900 Park Fare.

I have not been to Yak and Yeti. CapnJacks is okay but nothing special.

 

[mi*vida*loca]

Keep 1900 PF.

I've never been to Capn or Yak and Yeti but isn't Capn in DTD?? Maybe you could do CS at Wolfgang Express or Earl of Sandwich instead.

 

[PictureJumpr]

I agree with keeping 1900PF - of the three you list, that one is our favorite.

I'd drop Cap'n Jacks - if you've ever been to a Red Lobster you've been there, done that... except the part where Cap'n Jacks doesn't serve either crabs or lobster.

 

[dbk1029]

Yak & Yeti and Nine Dragons do have similar dishes on their menus. I would probably drop one of the two of those. Take a look at the menus for both and if you find that you are going to order something similar at both places then just pick one of the two.

 

[MickeyNicki]

I would dump 1900 PF...we ate there last month and while the charcters are fantastic the food was horrible...click on my Jan link to view tons of pics and full review

 

[ilovebassets]

Haven't eaten at the other two, but DON't drop yak and yeti.

 

[sarehm]

Drop Cap'n Jacks, awful food here! I loved Yak & Yeti

 

[Ginamarie]

I'd drop Cap'n Jacks for sure!

 

[PrincessDisney96]

I'd drop Capn' Jacks. I have heard that the food is nothing special. In our trip in July we had to cancel one of our ADRs and we dropped Capn' Jacks. All of the other choices you have listed, I have either enjoyed, or heard good reviews

 

[kat3668]

Yup another vote for dropping Capt Jacks... The Yak and Yeti was INCREDIBLE my last trip! You gotta try the egg rolls with plum sauce! Yum!!!

 

[Ariel Wanna-be]

Actually, I'd drop Coral Reef. JMO.

 

[java]

Now I have not been to the renovated Nine Dragons- but that would be the one I would drop.
The food gave us all massive headaches*thinking msg?? We are avid Chinese food eaters and do dim sum regularly so we are hard to please I guess but it did nothing for us.
I don't know if the food has improved since the renovation? I'll have to hunt around.
And Tony's would be the other one that would go if it were me.

So there I didn't pick any of the 3 you wanted to drop I made it more confusing. I actually liked Yak and Yeti- the steak and shrimp meal was devine!! And HUGE easily sharable imho. Never been to Capnjacks so I can't comment.
And the 1990 fare one was pretty good as far as the buffets go.

 

[zuly]

Nine Dragons,Cap n Jacks,Tony's

 

[cw21726]

Actually, I'd drop Coral Reef. JMO.

x2

 

[jill062604]

We HATED Tony's and Coral Reef. The food was terrible in both of those IMO..... We loved 1900 Park Fare. We are going abck for dinner in a few months!!! Whatever you do, go experience 1900 park fare!!

 

[AustinTink]

Knock off Yak and Yeti. It doesn't have "yak" in the name by accident.

 

[KEMdisney]

CapNJacks was the only place ive never NOT enjoyed.

 

[DisneyTabby]

I vote for Cap n Jack's especially since now they got rid of the lobster tails and the other entrees on the menu aren't that great compared to the other restaurants you have.

 

[BigMama]

i would eliminate coral reef the quality of food and service has dropped. if you do go dont get the crab cakes they reminded me of cat food