I had never stayed at a value until last summer. We stayed at POP. We all had very different opinions. My DD, 3.5 at the time, loved it because there was Lady and the Tramp, Baloo, etc. I felt our room was fine - clean, enough room, and pretty quiet - but I thought the atmosphere of the hotel was very loud and hectic. DH was fine with the atmosphere, but said he felt the room felt like a cheap hotel room to him - this is a surprise because he isn't usually too picky, especially when something's cheaper! We would rather choose a mod for the relaxed atmosphere and the room decor. The amenities just seemed a lot nicer and I like the calm after being in the parks all day. Can you get any discounts at Swan or Dolphin? We currently have a room booked there cheaper than a mod would be. Just a thought! I think if it came down to being able to go or not based on staying at a value, we would still stay at Pop or All Stars, but it would not be our first choice.