Help me choose!

[leebee]

We need a dinner for one night and I've narrowed it down to either Raglan Road or Olivia's (at Old Key West). Have you been to either, or both? Which would you choose, and why? (if we do Olivia's we'll probably take the boat to Disney Springs after supper.)

 

[jimandami]

Although I like Olivia's, I would choose Raglan Road. The food is good, atmosphere and dancing are great!

 

[agavegirl1]

Raglan Road. Better atmosphere and you will already BE in DS after dinner.

 

[mdelano4]

Raglan Road. IMHO better atmosphere and food.

 

[livyy]

Raglan Road all the way. It's one of my favorite Disney restaurants. They have amazing and authentic Irish cuisine and you cannot beat the atmosphere especially with the Irish dancing entertainment. It is always a must do for us!

 

[CarolynFH]

Having eaten at both, I'd pick Raglan Road. I think the food is equally tasty at RR & Olivia's, but RR is a lot more entertaining and fun. The fact that you'll probably end up in DS after dinner is additional reason to pick RR.

 

[winterman]

Keep in mind that in the evening Raglan Road is very busy (we had to wait more than 30 minutes for our ADR) and very noisy, even when the live entertainment is not on. Olivia's is much quieter. Also, tables are very close together in Raglan Road. Otherwise I would rate food and service equally good and I would definitely go back to either one. After you eat at RR, you have DS to explore but Olivia's is just a short, pleasant boat ride away from DS. Sorry, I 'm not much help.

 

[leebee]

I'd been thinking of driving to OKW, taking boat to/from DS from there, but then I'd have to drive back to AKL. Honestly, part of my interest in Olivia's was being able to take the boat ride to DS. I love to explore Disney transportation! We are staying 2 nights at AKL for my birthday; not a park trip so I'm planning other things to do, places to try that we wouldn't necessarily take the time for during a park trip. Not sure we have a lot of interest in exploring DS, but maybe instead we'll have dinner at RR, then take the boat ride to OKW (or POFQ) and back to DS for a drink. So, @winterman you actually were helpful!