If I had a choice between Shula's and Yachtsman, I would take Shula's.....I think it is far superior.. Also, I love Spoodles, a bit like a rustic Mediterranean bustling kitchen, with good food. I just love the decor and the castmembers are incredible there.
Cheeseburgers and shakes, Beaches and Cream at the Beach Club Resort, Cape May, an all you can eat Seafood All American Buffet is good as well. If you want a quiet time at the Yacht Club, their Galley restaurant serves dinner and I have always enjoyed the food there..
I did an Illumination cruise in December and it was a blast.....you would have to call and try to reserve that for when you are there and it can get costly....but it is a once in a lifetime kind of thing.. We enjoyed it so.