Transpo wise and getting there, they take about the same effort. Both are a little out of the way, but I would not use that to make a selection. Food wise, both are good. We have been Shula's fans in the past, and still are, but the Yachtsman was impressive in November.
To consider: Yachtsman takes the DDE card. There are not any discounts at Shula's. For us, with the DDE, Yachtsman gets the nod.