Like several here, we also tried the autotrain for the first time this past September. We opted only to take the train to FL and to drive home. The train was certainly a good experience and we have many happy memories. However, I am not sure we will choose this option again for FL travel (plan is to fly for our next trip in September).
The positive...great overall atmosphere from beginning to end. The waiting at the Sanford station was very pleasant and clean and nice...kids played on the playground, we bought a post card, talked to some train people. The food and entertainment included in the train were all very nice and a real perk. Trains in general (even restrooms) were clean and maintained. Some gorgeous scenery on the trip south including lots of water. Dinner was a big highlight for all of us...just really tasty and fun with the scenery and all in the dining car.
The bad....
The rails are bumpy and noisy. We were fine the first part of the trip, but I swear somewhere in the middle of the night the driver started off roading ;-) The speed picked up and the car in front of us made a huge racket and bounced in a distubing way! Just a tip, experienced train travelers with MP3 players were far less bothered by the noise.
Also, we had coach seats for us and 4 kids (ages dd1, dd5, ds10, and ds11), and while it was true that we could have all moved to have our own separate seats, I just was not comfortable doing that. It had not occurred to me until we were on the train, but the thought that someone could come up to one of my girls (1 and 5) asleep on their own seat while I was zonked on my own seat just really creeped me out! So dh sat with dd 1 (in her car seat for comfort, not safety) and I sat next to dd 5 while the two boys were together...not as comfy, but I felt the girls were safer.
We paid more overall to go by train one way and drive home to PA (with a hotel stop) than we would to fly, and that included an auto train special where all 4 kids travled free (though we paid additional for our vehicle since a mini van is considered oversized). We did not feel a real need for our car on property this trip and we did well when we used Disney to and from the airport the year before, so I think we will stick to flying in the furture. But I am glad to be able to say we experienced the auto train
