Yes--I voted other though b/c neither answer fit.
Yes, I had one (well 2 actually).
One went well (b/c was surprsed)
The other did not. I had found out by accident the week prior and the cirumstances around the whole thing was ridiculous.
The shower was thrown by someone who was on the outs with me and got po'd b/c I didn't "perform" to her expectations.
I was afraid to be caught--so I tried to be surprised and it went over by a lead balloon.
I was also chatted about during my own party and afterwards folks were spreading lies about how greedily I opened gifts. (which it didnt' occur to them that we videotaped and very clearly wasn't greedy at all.) Evidently I was expected to be a teary eyed sap googling over all the cuteness--and I don't ever do that anyway.
It was very disappointng when I found out that my conduct was not only horrible--but that I would lose a friend over it.
A complete disaster.
Oh--and I had to pee when I Got home and that was considered rude for an 8 month pregnant woman to do.
I say know whom you are surprising and create somethng you might enjoy--but the moment you set up a level of expectations that the guest of honor couldn't possibily meet...then you might reconsider the idea of a surprise party.
My other shower was not like that at all. It was thrown by my SIL and was a total surprise. I didn't cry or get sappy over gifts...and I was permitted to pee even without getting in trouble.
That shower was held first--so the fact that I got raked over the coals for the same conduct in my own home was too much to take.
To this day, I don't like baby showers held for me at all. Another friend insisted I have one for my second and it was very uncomfortable b/c I just don't know what people expect and refuse to be lied about again.
I'm also intimidated by going to baby showers of others and find that I'm studying all of the actions of the mom-to-be to see what I did wrong. And thus far, I haven't found too many women who act differently from me and yet they all manage to not be judged so harshly.