I'm usually very easy to please when eating at WDW. We tried Coral Reef for the first time this past summer. Out of all of our meals we ate, it was the worst. In fact, it was a huge disappointment. I'm glad we tried it because curiosity would have nagged at me until I did--it just sounds like a really fun dining experience, especially if you have kids. However, the ratings for this restaurant, at least for us, proved true. The food wasn't horrible, but it wasn't special by any means--very bland. We had a range at our table too--seafood, steak, & pasta for our kids. Nothing was great. The service was horrid! WDW is known for great service both at restaurants and throughout the parks. However, great service did not exist inside this restaurant while we were there. It was also a lot louder than what I had anticipated. It didn't have the intimate feel I thought it would have. Seeing the tank while dining was fun, but it didn't have the awe factor I had anticipated it would. More than anything, it was the very bland, poor quality food that will keep us from going back. For us, there's too many wonderful retaurants we'll go to again or try other new ones before we'd go back to CR again. With all that said, though, you could go and have a totally different experience. I have a friend who loves the place. Go try it and form your own opinion. At least then you'll know. You may find a winner or know not to go back. Good luck with your decision!