Has Karl Rov Committed Treason??? Newsweek and the CIA Leak

Status
Not open for further replies.
bsnyder said:
I guess it's all in the eye of the beholder, Rich. But do you have any idea how many google hits you get when you type in "BBC liberal bias"? There are even entire websites dedicated to the subject.

They are historically linked to the left wing, but recently there have been some question marks over this. It stems from a scrap that they had with our left wing government and, having acquired a new executive, seem to be slightly biased towards the right wing at the moment.

Andrew Marr, the political correspondent, is very left wing though. He does his best to be impartial, but it's still there. For this reason, I favour Reuters.

Newspapers are worse. Most are VERY left wing, the Telegraph is very right-wing and the Financial Times is impossible to read :crazy:



Rich::
 
Professor Mouse said:
You are buying the spin being given by Rove's attorney. No one from the Special Prosecutor's office has made that statement. You are relying on Rove's and Rove's attorney's attempt to spin the issue. The Rove-Luskin Leaks Rove and his attorney are trying to make a case that he was passive. That is not a believable story given the fact that Libby and Rove wrote Tenet's release but are claiming that they did not read the key document generated by the State Department. For Two Aides in Leak Case, 2nd Issue Rises The spin being painted by Rove's attorney is not believable. It has not been established that Rove and Libby did not go out and plant this story. In any event, under the law, it was still wrong to out a CIA agent despite who made the call.

Well, it certainly hasn't been established that Rove and Libby DID go out and plant the story. I've seen not one single fact to suggest that. Have you?

And why is the fact that Libby and Rove coordinated with Tenent on writing the press release relevant to the leak? Please try to use your own words, and common logic, rather than regurgitate the Democrat Underground talking points ad nauseum.

I'm not buying Rove's attorney's spin. But I'm also not buying the Democrats spin, especially the patently false and sickeningly pious comments that they're upset because this was an outrageous breach of vital national security. Give me a break. Where were they (and you) when Sandy Berger was stuffing classified 9/11 documents into his pants pockets??
 
bsnyder said:
Well, it certainly hasn't been established that Rove and Libby DID go out and plant the story. I've seen not one single fact to suggest that. Have you?

And why is the fact that Libby and Rove coordinated with Tenent on writing the press release relevant to the leak? Please try to use your own words, and common logic, rather than regurgitate the Democrat Underground talking points ad nauseum.

I'm not buying Rove's attorney's spin. But I'm also not buying the Democrats spin, especially the patently false and sickeningly pious comments that they're upset because this was an outrageous breach of vital national security. Give me a break. Where were they (and you) when Sandy Berger was stuffing classified 9/11 documents into his pants pockets??


Jim Marcinkowski, a former CIA case officer criticized Republican efforts to minimize the damage caused by the leak.

"Each time the political machine made up of prime-time patriots and partisan ninnies display their ignorance by deriding Valerie Plame as a mere paper pusher or belittling the varying degrees of cover used to protect our officers or continuing to play partisan politics with our national security, it's a disservice to this country," he added.

I'd say he hit the target with that one.
 
Professor Mouse said:
You are buying the spin being given by Rove's attorney. No one from the Special Prosecutor's office has made that statement.

Didn't Cooper and Novak both say that they testified to the GJ that they called Rove? How is that spin by Rove's attorney? Or are you saying that Cooper and Novak are spinning for Rove?
 
bsnyder said:
This is rich! Media Matters is in a tizzy because Toensing failed to disclose her friendship with Novak. Yet neither they nor any of the MSM have disclosed, in their numerous reporting on this story, that Time's Matt Cooper is married to Democratic political operative Mandy Grunwald.

As ThAnswr is so fond of saying: "You can't make this stuff up!" ;) ;)


What a comparison!

You really can't make this stuff up.
 
bsnyder said:
Good grief! I'm not arguing the merits of the brief, I'm questioning the news organizations' motives for signing on to it. Got that?

And I'm still waiting to see if you or anyone else has answers to the other questions I raised.

It's been about 3 days and counting since I asked you to cite some of the opinions that made Justice Ginsburg "extreme left". So far all you've done is cite your own opinion.

So, in the words of "Alfonse and Gaston": After you.
 
bsnyder said:
I have to admit, I don't have the faintest clue what's going on here. ...

Oh, and on the State Department memo....it clearly says it identified Ms. Plame by her maiden name. How did anyone get a hold of her CIA identity from that?
You were right in the first statement made above. The State Department Memo uses the name Valerie Wilson. Plame's Identity Marked As Secret
A classified State Department memorandum central to a federal leak investigation contained information about CIA officer Valerie Plame in a paragraph marked "(S)" for secret, a clear indication that any Bush administration official who read it should have been aware the information was classified, according to current and former government officials.

Plame -- who is referred to by her married name, Valerie Wilson, in the memo -- is mentioned in the second paragraph of the three-page document, which was written on June 10, 2003, by an analyst in the State Department's Bureau of Intelligence and Research (INR), according to a source who described the memo to The Washington Post.

The paragraph identifying her as the wife of former ambassador Joseph C. Wilson IV was clearly marked to show that it contained classified material at the "secret" level, two sources said. The CIA classifies as "secret" the names of officers whose identities are covert, according to former senior agency officials.
The State Department Memo is just one piece of the puzzle but an important piece. That memo uses the name Valerie Wilson and so Novak got her maiden name some place else.
 
ThAnswr said:
It's been about 3 days and counting since I asked you to cite some of the opinions that made Justice Ginsburg "extreme left". So far all you've done is cite your own opinion.

So, in the words of "Alfonse and Gaston": After you.

Wrong thread. Wrong debate. Go resurrect the other one if you like, and I'll be happy to give you some opinions, including the one where she wanted to ban Mother's Day and Father's Day.
 
bsnyder said:
Wrong thread. Wrong debate. Go resurrect the other one if you like, and I'll be happy to give you some opinions, including the one where she wanted to ban Mother's Day and Father's Day.

I don't have to resurrect it as it isn't dead.

Anyone can go to it and post to it anytime they want. If you care to cite her legal opinions that make her "extreme left", go ahead and do so. You don't me to resurrect anything.
 
Professor Mouse said:
You were right in the first statement made above. The State Department Memo uses the name Valerie Wilson. Plame's Identity Marked As Secret The State Department Memo is just one piece of the puzzle but an important piece. That memo uses the name Valerie Wilson and so Novak got her maiden name some place else.

Why is it an important piece? How does it fit at all? Her maiden name is the important one. Surely LOTS of people already knew her as Valerie Wilson. Novak couldn't have "outed" her if he didn't have her maiden name.
 
ThAnswr said:
You don't me to resurrect anything.

Not sure what you're trying to say here, but I did say "If you like". If not, that's fine too.

Care to add anything of substance to the Plame story?
 
bsnyder said:
Not sure what you're trying to say here, but I did say "If you like". If not, that's fine too.

Care to add anything of substance to the Plame story?

Out of the 614 posts to this thread, 34 of them are mine.

Feel free to browse and see if any are substantial.
 
Bet asked if anyone knew who Judy Miller's source was? Here is a possibility. SCOOP: John Bolton Was Regular Source for Judith Miller WMD and National Security Reporting
TWN has just learned from a highly placed source -- and in the right place to know -- that John Bolton was a regular source for Judith Miller's New York Times WMD and national security reports.

The source did not have any knowledge on whether Bolton was one of Miller's sources on the Valerie Plame story she was preparing, but argues that he was a regular source otherwise.

It's all "thickening."
Bush is not going to be able to get Bolton confirmed now and so it looks like Bolton will either have to withdraw or get the job by means of a recess appointment (a great way to tell the world that he is a lame duck and has no authority)
 
ThAnswr said:
Out of the 614 posts to this thread, 34 of them are mine.

Feel free to browse and see if any are substantial.

Let me make myself clearer. Care to add anything of substance today?
 
Professor Mouse said:
Bush is not going to be able to get Bolton confirmed now and so it looks like Bolton will either have to withdraw or get the job by means of a recess appointment (a great way to tell the world that he is a lame duck and has no authority)

Wow, talk about jumping to conclusions. It's breathtaking. And highly amusing, in an odd sort of way.
 
bsnyder said:
Wow, talk about jumping to conclusions. It's breathtaking. And highly amusing, in an odd sort of way.

Another "scoop" by the Professor. :rolleyes: Conclusion jumping as an Olympic event.

Any Vegas odds on this one??
 
bsnyder said:
Wow, talk about jumping to conclusions. It's breathtaking. And highly amusing, in an odd sort of way.
Bolton's nomination has been dead for some time now even before the latest revelations . With these revelations, the Democrats would love to call Bolton for some more hearings. If Bush wants Bolton to be ambassador to the UN, Bush's only option is a recess appointment.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom