Hannah Montana/t1 diabetes misinformation--Disney pulled the episode!

Pooh Crew

DIS Veteran
Joined
Apr 21, 2005
Messages
884
November is diabetes awareness month and Hannah Montana's Oliver is diagnosed with diabetes on the episode titled "No Sugar, Sugar". Unfortunately, the episode is filled with inaccurate information regarding diabetes--specifically type 1 diabetes. Parents of children with type 1 have written to Disney to ask that this episode be pulled--all to no avail. We are concerned that the theme of the show (no sugar!) could lead to a child who is suffering from low blood glucose being denied treatment (which is a juice or other quick sugar like fruit snacks) by well-meaning friends. If a diabetic is having a "low" he or she MUST HAVE sugar!

So, as the parent of a child with type 1 diabetes, may I please try to head off some of the other misinformation that will be presented by this so-called "comedy" show?

1. My son can have sugar. Matter of fact, he can have just as much sugar as any of my other children. I don't want him or any of my other children eating a two pound bag of chocolate, but he CAN eat like any other child. He just has to take insulin to allow his body to convert the sugar into energy. (And just for the record, for the most part, we are concerned about all carbohydrates--not just sugar. For my son, 40 carbs of pasta has the same blood glucose effect as 40 carbs of chocolate.)

2. He cannot "just take his insulin" and all will be fine. He has to check his blood glucose--sometimes as often as 12 times a day. He has to check it before he eats and then two hours after he eats to ensure that he is within his target range...which he usually is.

3. For a type 1 diabetic, insulin is delivered with a shot (which can be up to five a day for some children) or using an insulin pump which uses a canula (tubing) that is inserted into the skin every three days. There is no pill for type 1.

I don't think the show actually says Oliver has type 1, but with him being a kid, that is what we are led to believe. Type 1 is not caused by diet and/or lack of exercise. This disease requires almost constant monitoring to ensure the health of my child. I hate that it is being presented as the butt of a joke on a show that millions of children watch and emulate. :headache: :sad2:

There is no cure for type 1 diabetes.

Thank you for listening.

edited to add that Disney's public relations department says that they have pulled the episode and will show a Jonas Brothers special that night instead! :woohoo:
 
:hug: I hope your baby stays healthy and free of additional complications until a cure is found.
 
De-lurking and btt for you. FYI-according to some posters on the CWD board, Disney responded and says they will not air it this Sunday and will review the situation.

Woo Hoo!
 

Sigh. Sounds like all Disney was trying to do was to try and score a few points with those who have diabetes. The least they could do is fact check.
 
De-lurking and btt for you. FYI-according to some posters on the CWD board, Disney responded and says they will not air it this Sunday and will review the situation.

Woo Hoo!

Yes. Several people got responses from Disney public relations dept. which said that they were pulling the episode and would show a Jonas Brothers special repeat that night instead. They are going to re-evaluate the episode. While I realize that the largest part of the HM audience would have no clue that it was so incorrect, I am just about moved to tears that Disney would pull the episode. :thumbsup2
 
:hug: I hope your baby stays healthy and free of additional complications until a cure is found.

Thank you! He's an absolute trooper...never complains, never slows down, just a joy to be around. He charms everyone he meets. I keep telling him that I hope he grows up to use his powers for good and not evil. ;)
 
You know, this thought just occurred to me, the people that probably wrote that episode are older (don't take that the wrong way, I'm 30, I just meant compared to the kids), most likely in their 40's, maybe older? When they probably learned about diabetes, the information they are giving out in the episode was treated as fact. I can remember as a kid having a diabetic kid in class and for every party he got a SUGAR FREE treat. On Halloween he never got candy because we were all told that he couldn't have any sugar. It would have never dawned on us to feed him sugar since it was pounded into our heads that he COULDN'T have it. I'm only 30, so this was 20 years ago? It wasn't until recently when a young diabetic friend of mine told me that his doctor was allowing him to eat whatever he wanted (probably sometime in the last 6 months). So honestly, I'm sure what they wrote is what they knew and assumed it was correct. If you do not deal with it every day, you tend to fall back on what you know and what you've learned over the years. Just something to think about...
 
You know, this thought just occurred to me, the people that probably wrote that episode are older (don't take that the wrong way, I'm 30, I just meant compared to the kids), most likely in their 40's, maybe older? When they probably learned about diabetes, the information they are giving out in the episode was treated as fact. I can remember as a kid having a diabetic kid in class and for every party he got a SUGAR FREE treat. On Halloween he never got candy because we were all told that he couldn't have any sugar. It would have never dawned on us to feed him sugar since it was pounded into our heads that he COULDN'T have it. I'm only 30, so this was 20 years ago? It wasn't until recently when a young diabetic friend of mine told me that his doctor was allowing him to eat whatever he wanted (probably sometime in the last 6 months). So honestly, I'm sure what they wrote is what they knew and assumed it was correct. If you do not deal with it every day, you tend to fall back on what you know and what you've learned over the years. Just something to think about...


You are absolutely correct! That's why there was such a huge push from parents to get the correct information out there. Now we know soooooo much more about it. It's ALL carbohydrates, not just sugar. From our diagnosis five years ago when ds was not even 2 yet, the endocrinologist has stressed for us to remember that he is a child first, and a child with diabetes second. The dr actually told us it was better for him to have the same exact thing that all the other kids were having--knowing that he can have something from a young age supposedly reduces the diabetes rebellion that typically occurs during the teen years. You know, making stuff off-limits always increases the temptation!

We always joke that type 1 diabetes "ain't your grandma's diabetes!" :laughing:
 
Personally, I think they should run the episode as it is, then add a PSA at the end about the changes that have taken place. That way adults that may watch with kids that know something different have something to relate to, then a non-threatening way to see what's different. Knowing what I used to know, if I didn't know a younger diabetic and saw an episode of a show where they were giving a diabetic sugar, I think I would probably freak because it was pounded into my head later that the only time to give sugar is in a crisis. :confused3
 
Pooh Crew, thanks for that post.

DS8 has had Type 1 for a little over 2 years. My big boss at work was just giving me a hard time last week b/c I let DS have something sugarary (sp) for dessert. She didn't think I should do that...Luckily, another worker whose wife has had T1 almost all her life came in and backed me up, saying that is was perfectly fine for diabetics to have sugar. I don't think my boss believed me until my co-worker came in.

I hope they do this episode w/ all the information correct. DS watches HM a lot and I think he would like to see that.
 
I'm part of the CWD board and while I've been too busy with school work to add letters and phone calls to the campaign I was happy to see this morning that the response from Disney was so positive.

With 2 type 1 kids the amount of miss information is out there every single day and it is very frustrating. Kudos for Disney for doing the right thing. Now if we could only get them to provide basic carb counts at the parks they would be helping even more.
 
I agree: I do not think anyone should get their medical information from a situation comedy. Or, for that fact, from any of those 'medical dramas' that seem to be so popular.

Indeed, I recall a few years back when Reba was on. My wife and I missed a couple of episodes (I think two in a row). When we got back to watching Reba we discovered that while we were gone the daughter had begun drinking alcoholic, become an alcoholic, and gone 'dry', all in that two week time-period. It used to mildly irritate us when, in future episodes, they would make some reference to how 'she used to be an alcoholic'.
 
Yes. Several people got responses from Disney public relations dept. which said that they were pulling the episode and would show a Jonas Brothers special repeat that night instead. They are going to re-evaluate the episode. While I realize that the largest part of the HM audience would have no clue that it was so incorrect, I am just about moved to tears that Disney would pull the episode. :thumbsup2

Thank God!!! I have been following on the CWD website but this is the first I heard on the episode being pulled. I have to go over there now and celebrate.
 
I agree: I do not think anyone should get their medical information from a situation comedy. Or, for that fact, from any of those 'medical dramas' that seem to be so popular.

Indeed, I recall a few years back when Reba was on. My wife and I missed a couple of episodes (I think two in a row). When we got back to watching Reba we discovered that while we were gone the daughter had begun drinking alcoholic, become an alcoholic, and gone 'dry', all in that two week time-period. It used to mildly irritate us when, in future episodes, they would make some reference to how 'she used to be an alcoholic'.

Yep! And I can personally testify that giving birth to triplets is NOTHING like Phoebe on Friends!:lmao: Ya know, one would think that people would know that, but I have actually had people tell me that they saw that Friends episode where Phoebe had her babies and so they knew what it was like for us. Ummmm...ok, sure you do. ;)
 
You know, this thought just occurred to me, the people that probably wrote that episode are older (don't take that the wrong way, I'm 30, I just meant compared to the kids), most likely in their 40's, maybe older? When they probably learned about diabetes, the information they are giving out in the episode was treated as fact. I can remember as a kid having a diabetic kid in class and for every party he got a SUGAR FREE treat. On Halloween he never got candy because we were all told that he couldn't have any sugar. It would have never dawned on us to feed him sugar since it was pounded into our heads that he COULDN'T have it. I'm only 30, so this was 20 years ago? It wasn't until recently when a young diabetic friend of mine told me that his doctor was allowing him to eat whatever he wanted (probably sometime in the last 6 months). So honestly, I'm sure what they wrote is what they knew and assumed it was correct. If you do not deal with it every day, you tend to fall back on what you know and what you've learned over the years. Just something to think about...

Being a type 1 Diabetic myself...almost 28 years (diagnosed at age 11) the times have REALLY changed. Back then it was drilled into my head NO SUGAR. Over the years it has all be re-evaulated and it is all based on carbs. I think the "older" people are a little mis-informed and you could have a point. I remember people calling it Sugar Diabetes. :mad: Even today I will grab a mini size candy bar and people will look at me funny. Or someone will bring in a treat to work and say "I didn't offer you any because I didn't think you could have it". So many misconceptions.

I love the idea of them bringing awareness to kids through the show, but it needs to be the correct information. I am glad they pulled the show for now. They should speak to Nick Jonas!!!! ;)
 
Children with diabetes

It is a wonderfully supportive site for parents whose children have diabetes. There are forums for type 1 and type 2.
Thanks! I will check that out, I don't think I have seen it before.
 
What is the CWD website?

A godsend support message board and website for those of us with kids with Type 1. It also supports adults with T1 and T2.

Best of all we have a convention at Disney every other summer.
 










Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE














DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Back
Top