I just spent an hour reading all 10 pages of that thread about the alcohol policy change. As we stated on this thread earlier, "changes" "cutbacks" whatever you want to call them happen on every cruise line. We never carried our own alcohol on
DCL anyway, so didn't affect us, but I see people being upset if it was something that affects them. I will say however, we LOVED the ultimate beverage package on our NCL cruise. It was awesome to just order whatever, wherever. We also bought the beverage package on Allure last year, but the fact that it seems to be "included" with NCL bookings these days, really was an awesome perk for us.
As for entertainment, we only did the Star, so can't speak for all NCL. We were pleasantly surprised by the quality and how much we loved every show onboard! And we don't get "bored" with DCL shows-literally we have sat through every show on all 14 sailings, every time. I never get bored with Golden Mickeys, or even the opening and closing night shows. But we thought NCL shows were amazing! Oh-and sweetpee-if you're still reading this thread, we also were blown away by Chicago on Allure.
Looking forward to hearing your guys' experiences on your first NCL cruises, as well as Escape reviews, as that is our next one next spring!