Greatest Survivor of All-Time

[DonkeyGreatness]

Who do you think it is? Obviously Sandra is the only two time winner so you can't go wrong in selecting her but there are lots of people who could probably qualify.

 

[redlight]

Richard Hatch because he was the first. Annoying as he is, you have to give him that.

 

[disneyfav4ever]

As much as I don't like him, I think it might be Russel. Or maybe Boston Rob.

 

[bunkkinsmom]

Greatest? - Sandra
Smartest? - Russell
Most Devious? - Boston Rob (his first time in)
Most Fun to Watch? - Rupert
Most Fun to Look At? - Ozzie
Most Genuine? - Ethan

My personal favorite? - Boston Rob. He's the only person
I would pull for over Russell. Russell deserved it.

 

[redlight]

I'd also give Tina Wesson props.

 

[Cat0727]

oooh good thread.

I'd probably say Boston Rob- strategic play and performance in the challenges (especially the puzzles) were really good.

 

[tammymacb]

I voted for Sandra because I love her game and think she's a very smart player. I would have voted for Tom Westman if he'd been an option. Man, when Tom won, he was gooooood.

 

[Pakey]

Boston Rob.

 

[LBIJim]

Of the choices listed, Pavarti.

Can't consider these two "great" players, but I enjoyed them as well: Ami and Eliza.

Can hardly even remember the recently completed season, it was so lame.

Jim

 

[DeluxePrincess]

Parvati Shallow gets my vote simply because she's lasted in the game more days than anyone else....ever. She's only won once, but always managed to make it to the end, or very near the end. People seem to think she relied solely on her feminine ways to go far, but quite a few ladies have helped her out along the way.

 

[gometros]

Who the heck was Bob Crowley?

And why isn't Fabio in that list?

 

[mefordis]

How could Rob be the best survivor? He got his butt beat badly by Russell. I don't particularly root for Russell but come on! I know he didn't know what Russell was all about, but isn't that what would make a great survivor player -- to beat someone in which you have no knowledge of their capabilities?

I was rooting for Rob against Russell, but I feel like he was sleeping during that game. His head was not in it.

 

[Manhattan Princess]

Rob is probably my favorite player of all time, but I think Parvati understood the game the most and was probably the best player.

 

[Sorsha]

Of those listed? Parvati. But you forgot to include Ozzie, and he would get my vote ANYTIME, for ANYTHING.

 

[gometros]

There's another player not listed, who didn't win, but even Probst said he was probably one of the best players. That was the other Rob from Boston Rob's first season.

 

[krcit]

Boston Rob is my all-time favorite player but I think the greatest player has to be someone who won, right? I would go with Sandra because she won twice or Tom because he just dominated his season( an he's hot

 

[leagirl12]

Gotta give props to Yao-Man who I think was the first one to make a fake immunity idol...that was awesome!

 

[DonkeyGreatness]

There's another player not listed, who didn't win, but even Probst said he was probably one of the best players. That was the other Rob from Boston Rob's first season.

A poll can only have 12 choices max so relax a little bit.

 

[lacrosse_lady72]

For me, you cannot be a "greatest" if you haven't won. With that said, I voted for Parvati. She's been there the most and did you see Fans vs. Favorites? A masterpiece. And she was able to actually control Russell in HvV. I think if I could vote for anyone else, I would say Richard on the sole reason (in why he's greater than the other winners) is that he went into the game without being able to see another season beforehand.

 

[OceanAnnie]

Gotta give props to Yao-Man who I think was the first one to make a fake immunity idol...that was awesome!

I thought so too! I really like him.