Greatest Survivor of All-Time

[DonkeyGreatness]

For me, you cannot be a "greatest" if you haven't won. With that said, I voted for Parvati. She's been there the most and did you see Fans vs. Favorites? A masterpiece. And she was able to actually control Russell in HvV. I think if I could vote for anyone else, I would say Richard on the sole reason (in why he's greater than the other winners) is that he went into the game without being able to see another season beforehand.

Richard was pretty good although his performance in all-stars wasn't that memorable. Colby got him out pretty quickly if I remember correctly.

 

[bunkkinsmom]

Of those listed? Parvati. But you forgot to include Ozzie, and he would get my vote ANYTIME, for ANYTHING.

THIS!!!!!

 

[4greatboys]

Yes, LOVE Ozzy! Best physical game--and not bad to look at! However Russell played the best strategic game.


Bob Crowley winner of Gabon. Like him too.

 

[DonkeyGreatness]

Of those listed? Parvati. But you forgot to include Ozzie, and he would get my vote ANYTIME, for ANYTHING.

lol what qualifications would he have for being the "greatest" survivor other than his looks?

 

[4greatboys]

lol what qualifications would he have for being the "greatest" survivor other than his looks?

Did you watch his season? He kicked butt in challenges. He only lost by 1 vote. I would definately rate him higher than Cirie or Amanda.

 

[tinatark]

Terry Dietz - retired Navy Pilot. He was awesome in challenges and with people. Played the year the Yoga instructor won... the final challenge was a water lily you had to "balance" on... and we wonder how the yoga instructor won the final immunity challenge? LOL. Terry was awesome, and he deserved to win that game.

 

[DonkeyGreatness]

Did you watch his season? He kicked butt in challenges. He only lost by 1 vote. I would definately rate him higher than Cirie or Amanda.

I did watch and thought he played a great game. But Yul had him beat in every sense except the physical component.

Ozzie played a second time though and didn't do so hot if memory serves correctly.

 

[mackeysmom]

I voted for Richard Hatch simply because he didn't the luxury of having seen any prior seasons. His win was the most well-deserved - in my opinion.

 

[4greatboys]

I did watch and thought he played a great game. But Yul had him beat in every sense except the physical component.

Ozzie played a second time though and didn't do so hot if memory serves correctly.

Yeah his second go round on FvF could have been better. Still one of the best though imo.

 

[4greatboys]

Terry Dietz - retired Navy Pilot. He was awesome in challenges and with people. Played the year the Yoga instructor won... the final challenge was a water lily you had to "balance" on... and we wonder how the yoga instructor won the final immunity challenge? LOL. Terry was awesome, and he deserved to win that game.

ITA! Terry was great. I was disappointed that he hasn't been back either in FvF or HvV.
Danielle won that challange and took Aras to the final instead of Terry.

 

[bunkkinsmom]

I did watch and thought he played a great game. But Yul had him beat in every sense except the physical component.

Ozzie played a second time though and didn't do so hot if memory serves correctly.

Ozzie was too nice to people, had no sense of "game". However, in physical challenges he was the man. Either way, very pretty.

 

[gometros]

A poll can only have 12 choices max so relax a little bit.

What relax. I just stated an opinion. Sorry I wasn't espousing the glories of Russell Hantz.

 

[Metro West]

I'm going with Sandra...the only two time winner.

 

[Por1968]

Another player not listed that could be considered is Brian Heidek, the winner of Survivor Thailand. He is forgotten because he never played in All Stars and it was not a memorable season. However, I don't think anyone won as easily as Brian did.