Went the third week of December. 4 adults, 2 children. Three of us, foreign-born Chinese. They made a big deal when we entered about celebrating a 50th birthday. We ordered quite a variety of food - the $46 steak, the Lobster Chow Fun, Peking Duck, sushi, other apps. It was the most underwhelming meal of the week, and I don't go to Disney for the food. Oh, and not even a toothpick as a 50th birthday acknowledgement. And, hey, we don't care about it, but why did you mention the birthday at the outset if you were going to ignore it? Completely ignore it, then, and don't mention it. I would have forgotten that I was asked the month before when making the reservation about any celebrations.
In regards to the food, for the Lobster Chow Fun, it was definitely an attempt to be generous, with more lobster than noodles. BUT, working lobster out of the partial remaining shell with chopsticks at a finer restaurant...eh...I'd have gladly traded 2/3 of the lobster for shelled lobster and a boatload more chow fun. That's the thing with chow fun...you order it because you LIKE noodles...big fat stinkin' noodles.

The sushi the night we were there was quite good, and the steak made our meat and potatoes guy happy. Though, he was a bit surprised that the steak was IT. Might have been a wee bit of garnish. Maybe. I don't remember.
Even though it'll be a long time before we'll head there again, try it for yourself. Not everyone has the same background or access to Asian food, and just like the rest of WDW, on any given day, it could be a really good choice for a meal. If nothing else, the room is pretty spectacular.
My husband, just read this review and said it's more complimentary than he would have been. He did like my toothpick joke though.
