This is my take on why Taylor Swift won last night...
The Grammy membership was trying to make up for Kanye West's outburst at the VMAs. Pure & simple. IF he had just kept his mouth shut (yeah, RIGHT, Kanye never met a mike he didn't want to hog), I bet Taylor would not have won as much as she did.
It's nothing new, often the big entertainment awards get handed-out for all the wrong reasons, like Elizabeth Taylor's Oscar for "Butterfield 8". (Most observers would agree that it was a true sympathy award, the performance didn't deserve it, she got it because her husband Mike Todd has been killed that year in a plane crash.) These awards sometimes get handed out for sympathy and sometimes they get handed out for a body of work...all sorts of reasons that have little to do with the performance/album/whatever that is supposedly under consideration.
And after Taylor Swift's live ((shudder)) performance last night, I doubt that next year she'll win as much. Her albums and her songs might truly be worthy of nominations, but I think that "singing" last night is going to seal the deal with the performer/voters.
I'm sorry, I think she's a lovely girl and she seems very nice but in my opinion her vocals are simply too flat and weak unless she gets auto-tuned to the max in the editing-suite.
agnes!