On our June trip, we did both the Luau and Hoop Dee Doo Revue. I was so worried about the Luau after reading the poor reviews, but we enjoyed it overall. In our opinion, we preferred the FOOD at the Luau and the ENTERTAINMENT at Hoop Dee Doo.
We had excellent service at the luau, our drinks were never less than half full, and our kids were offered a box meal in addition to the regular food offerings. Our seats were okay (cat. 2), definitely could have been worse. The only negative for us was that the show seemed long...both kids fell asleep at the table, we had to wake them up so they could walk out!
Enjoy,
Jennifer