We haven't tried the Perfect Gift yet, but we will for the next cruise.
We ordered the romance package from Disney for our 25th anniv, and were really, really disappointed. The fruit was a saaran wrapped soup bowl of grapes, the cheese was like 4 or five really small wheels (1.5 in), all the same, the box of chocolates was like 4" SQ, and everything was thrown loose (even the two champagne glasses) in three boxes tied together with a silk rose. The "bottle" of champagne was a small split, we had to make our own "priority reservations at Palos" and stand in line to make the reservations for the upper body massages that were included, and then get on the phone at least three times because the package was mislabled, and no one was sure about the massages that were supposed to be included. Not a bargain at $170!!!!
I have NEVER read a bad review about Shirley at the Perfect Gift and when we go this fall for My parents 50th, she's going to get my business!!!!! If you didn't see what you wanted on the webpage, just call her. From what I've read, she'll customize anything your heart desires!!!!