A gift certifiacte to a reliogious store would be nice. Also, how about a statue of her favorite saint(if you know which one that is)or her namesake saint(if she is named after one). When my goddaughter made her First Communion, I did a whole Mary/Blessed Mother thing, because her name is Mary. It was very nice. I got her a statue, 2 books about Mary, and a little card with all the Mary prayers on it.