Gideon's vs Summerhouse cookies

[thanxfornoticin]

the real answer in this debate is the Jack Jack Cookie Num Num from Hollywood Studios

And I thought we were the only ones!! We'd do Jack Jack most anytime!!

And we're probably a minority, but we don't need to wait in line or order from either Gideons or SH! We just don't think the cookies live up to the hype - just our opinion!! We're one less party in line for those who do want them!

Jack Jack line? Yes.....!

 

[FLCA026]

And I thought we were the only ones!! We'd do Jack Jack most anytime!!

And we're probably a minority, but we don't need to wait in line or order from either Gideons or SH! We just don't think the cookies live up to the hype - just our opinion!! We're one less party in line for those who do want them!

Jack Jack line? Yes.....!

guess we need to put that on our list!

 

[Disnsyncey]

the real answer in this debate is the Jack Jack Cookie Num Num from Hollywood Studios

SO DELICIOUS!!!! I make sure I bring a ziploc to take the rest with me after my "breakfast" HAHAHA

 

[FLCA026]

SO DELICIOUS!!!! I make sure I bring a ziploc to take the rest with me after my "breakfast" HAHAHA

We live in California so we will try them here. I always bring zip lock baggies for treats.

 

[thanxfornoticin]

We live in California so we will try them here. I always bring zip lock baggies for treats.

That's where we experienced them for the first time! Recently enjoyed them at HS, too, even if the theming for them is better at DL!!

 

[hhisc16]

Another good cookie option is at Cake Bake.

 

[J-Dog]

Another good cookie option is at Cake Bake.

I'm going to guess that they are approximately $30 per cookie.

 

[Pens Fan]

Gideon's was a one and done for me. The only cookie I was wowed by was the coffee cake one. The rest are just too rich for me and way to many chips and "stuff". Also I'm not going to stand in a 30 minute line or get in a virtual queue for a cookie again. It's a cookie.

The Summer House cookies were delicious. And you could just walk up and buy one - go figure! I am also baffled by the comparison of Gideon's to Crumbl. They are nothing alike .

 

[hhisc16]

I'm going to guess that they are approximately $30 per cookie.

Both cookies are about the same price.
Cake Bake was small cookie vs. the massive Gideons.

 

[FLCA026]

Gideon's was a one and done for me. The only cookie I was wowed by was the coffee cake one. The rest are just too rich for me and way to many chips and "stuff". Also I'm not going to stand in a 30 minute line or get in a virtual queue for a cookie again. It's a cookie.

The Summer House cookies were delicious. And you could just walk up and buy one - go figure! I am also baffled by the comparison of Gideon's to Crumbl. They are nothing alike .

I waited for an hour! I thought I needed to finally do it. There was no virtual que! It was hot but I did enjoy conversation with people standing with me! . We got a bunch and tried them. I like the coffee cake one also but not sure I would wait in line for an hour again.