Daniele
Nell
- Joined
- Oct 16, 2009
- Messages
- 711
Oh Nell, dont be down!! Enjoy that cool weather! Dont forget we love you!!
Here is Diane's response to my question about the pumpkin, black soybeans, and I had also asked her what about Thanksgiving dinner...looks like we are NOT to have the pumpkin until step 3!! OMG
_________________________________________________________________
Hi Robin,
Pumpkin is the same as acorn, butternut, winter squash in that 1 cup is an 11-20 gram choice High Impact Carb on Step 3. If she has a recipe that keeps the total net grams of carb to 5 grams or less, it can be a 5x5 carb choice....but please be careful.....
Black soy beans are a neutral food on all steps.....
As for Thanksgiving dinner:
If you are on Step 1..."anything that happens within a 5 hour block (like Thanksgiving long dinner/dessert) is considered one "hit" to the pancreas. Because the pancreas and liver are on vacation on Step 1, hitting them with carb over 5 grams is like throwing ice and gatorade on the coach after the Superbowl. So...I advise anyone on Step 1 who wants to celebrate Thanksgiving with pie, pumpkin, dressing, potato....to add a full 3 days onto the end of their eight weeks. They also need to know that once you have a major break like this, your cravings will return so the next 3 days after Thanksgiving will be hard.
If you are on Step 2 or Maintenance at Thanksgiving...."anything that happens within a 5 hour block is considered one "hit" to the pancreas, but your pancreas is not totally relaxed. As long as you get right back on your program within 5 hours of the feast, this meal will count as one hit to the pancreas. If you have more than 2 hits in one week, you will need 10 days of Step 1 to "clean up."
Hope this helps......Diane
Thank you for sharing that. It clears it up quite a bit. Ok... No pumpkin, and no squash for me! That's ok, I like sweet potato anyway.

OH, OH. I've had KW pumpkin pie 2 times, and pumpkin soup more than once!!!
All times, I counted as a 5x5 (within my 11-20). This gets really confusing. At times she says use the 5x5 rule for foods other than on the arrow chart and then she says not so good on the pumpkin. What do you guys think? Do I need to return to step1. I'm hoping not since I counted the pumpkin as part of an 11-20 
I think this plan is a little more forgiving that we're giving it credit for being. I believe what Diane said should serve as a warning for Thanksgiving and I'm so glad she explained it to Robin. However, I shall be having my pumpkin pie, I serve it only twice a year and will partake. I trust KW's thoughts on the pumpkin and honestly believe you're safe. I've not been spot on for a couple of weeks now and I'm still losing so there must be some forgiveness with it somehow.
But I think you're right. I pulled the pumpkin can out of the garbage and for all the pumpkin in the recipe divided by 6 servings, it comes out to 2.3 grams carb per serving since the pumpkin is the only food that's not neutral in the recipe. Pumpkin's less carb than sweet potato and higher in fiber, so go figure..Thanks, I think I'll not worry about it. 
I should be cleaning it up, but I'm not!
It might be a nice stopping off point for your honeymoon or when you start your travels. Humm?







and driving with the windows open!
Robin, this is cool beans!





I always tell myself that if I quit I'll gain weight but I gain anyway..I'm thinking of trying Zyban once my weight is off. My Dr. has recommended it for me since I don't have any depression issues. Pony, you and me girl, before too long huh? Give em up. But before we do, let's hang out with a few Baileys and cigs