FURIOUS at Credit Card Company - What would you do?

pooh6890

DIS Veteran
Joined
Sep 9, 2000
Messages
1,413
I have a Juniper credit card which is issued from Carnival Cruise Lines. I only took the card because you can rack up miles for cruises. Here is the problem. My credit limit is $900. I made an on-line payment on 9/21/06 for $919.53. It came out of my bank account on 9/22/06. It has already cleared my account. I tried to use my card last night (9/25) and it was declined. Luckily I had cash on me for gas. So, this morning I go online and check to see if there was a problem. It shows a credit balance of $33.16 and a credit available of -0-. So, I called them. I was told there was a HOLD on my payment for 7 to 10 days. Some crap about FDIC guidelines. Sorry don't understand that one.....hang up and call again. Ask the same questions.......i pay you, you take out the money and it has cleared my account.....says that I could stop payment so there is a hold.....i tell them...it has already cleared my account....how could I put a hold on something already done? I complain....they will raise my limit so I can use my card....now, that is not the point. How can you hold a payment that has already cleared my account.....get nowhere so hang up.....Call again and am told that it is their policy to hold funds for 7 to 10 days......oh really, the last two payments I made were not held and had available funds THE NEXT DAY...then he tells me that I have already called twice and now 3 times and why do I keep calling? I ask to speak to a manager and HE TELLS ME NO!!!!!!!!!!!!! What? Tells me that I have been told the answer and is there anything else he can do for me? Yes, give me your last name and employee number.....gives me the employee number but no last name.......Well, I am so frustrated at this point I hang up. Am I wrong here? How can they hold funds already received. Isn't that some sort of fraud. I plan on having them refund me the credit balance and will NOT use their card, but what else can I do? They say the funds will be available on OCTOBER 2nd........I am flabbergasted that this kind of stuff happens to good customers.. I would bet Carnival doesn't know how their customers are being treated through this bank..............So what would you do?????? :confused3
 
I would cancel the card and get a regular card that you can get rewards on. I have a Chase rewards for travel and even though I spend a fee for the program, the card is free. I can get airline, unrestricted, cruises, rail, rental cars, and best of all can redeam for gift certificates to restaurants and stores I frequent. I got my D50 NIkon digital SLR camera last summer from my airline points. I had $800. in points and had to pay just under a hundred for a few extras I bought. I now have another $400 waiting to be spent.

I charge everything on my card and pay it off each month. I NEVER run a balance and that is how I accumulate points so fast.
 
Have them call your bank and your bank will tell them funds have cleared - they should then release your hold. They do the 7-10 day hold because of waiting for checks to clear and because you were up to your limit and paid it off. Some people would knowingly write a bad check just so come credit line is made available.
 
Hi. I work for a bank so I help this info helps. Some credit card companys are now holding your avail. credit for up to 10 days when a payment comes out of your acct as an ACH ( automatic clearing house) which is routing number and your acct number. The reason behind it is.....if you wrote them a real check once it clears you cannot put a stop payment on it so they know they are paid and your cant do anything about it. With an ach ....once the payment comes out of your acct you can actually reverse it. Its called an ACH revocation. So cc companies are now holding your available funds to make sure you dont reverse it. Only thing they dont realize is you actually have 90 DAYS to do a reversal so holding for 10 days is really pointless. They want to make sure they dont make credit avail to you....you run it all up and then reverse your payment so that you have all your $$ back plus were able to use your cards.....Of course you'd have to have the mentality of a thief to do this.....but you'd be surprised what people do.....believe me I see it ALL.....everyday.

Hope that helped. Doesnt make it any better but maybe you'll understand a little better. And they dont always do it....depends on the size of your payment and yours was pretty large.
 
I can't remember the dollar amount but I tried to make a large payment at the register once on my Sears Mastercard and my payment was denied at the register because it was too big. :confused3 The clerk told me I had to mail it in. Um, okay, except that if I would have mailed it in, factoring the mail time, it would have been late.

Maybe CC companies just don't like it when consumers pay off their balances. Just a thought.
 
r5moores said:
Hi. I work for a bank so I help this info helps. Some credit card companys are now holding your avail. credit for up to 10 days when a payment comes out of your acct as an ACH ( automatic clearing house) which is routing number and your acct number. The reason behind it is.....if you wrote them a real check once it clears you cannot put a stop payment on it so they know they are paid and your cant do anything about it. With an ach ....once the payment comes out of your acct you can actually reverse it. Its called an ACH revocation. So cc companies are now holding your available funds to make sure you dont reverse it. Only thing they dont realize is you actually have 90 DAYS to do a reversal so holding for 10 days is really pointless. They want to make sure they dont make credit avail to you....you run it all up and then reverse your payment so that you have all your $$ back plus were able to use your cards.....Of course you'd have to have the mentality of a thief to do this.....but you'd be surprised what people do.....believe me I see it ALL.....everyday.
That's a great summary. :thumbsup2

I'm not sure that cancelling the credit card will really help that much with this specific issue, if this is common practice at credit card companies. However, any company that won't put me in touch with a manager on request doesn't deserve my business. I'd cancel the credit card on those grounds alone.
 
I'm not up to date on credit card policies. I have never heard of this and have never encountered it myself. I don't don't totally agree on a company holding your funds for 7 days because you can reverse it. I paid the wrong company a huge amount on line and didn't notice it for a few days. When I called the bank they said there was nothing they could do. I would have to wait until the company sends me the overage. I had to come up with the money to pay the right company until I got my money back, which by the way they took their sweet time on. :rolleyes: This may just be my bank though.

I agree I would not base not using this card because of this policy, for me it would be..
1. The embarrassment from my card being denyed
2. The poor customer service
3. The poor customer service
4. I was hung up on
5. The way the employee spoke to me and refused to send me to a supervisor
6. Did I say poor customer service

To me if you treat me poorly you no longer get any of my money!
 
I also had a problem with Sears Mastercard. I'd made a trip to Tallahassee and had put it on my card. I also put a new laptop on the card. I sent a check to pay off my entire balance. The check had cleared my bank account. According to Sears website, I had my full credit limit available. I tried to use the card to make a $20 purchase at DTD. It was declined. I called their customer service and was told they had put a temporary hold on my account because I had sent in a large payment.

So, the moral of this story is that you can carry a large balance and make small payments and still use your card. If you make a large payment, you are penalized. It seems very odd to me.

This is the same card that had a hold put on it when I made two $200 purchases last Christmas. They said it was for security purposes. What good is a card you can't use? I closed the account. I don't need it and I don't like playing games.
 
I would call back and insist on a manager. I would then explain that I was canceling their card because I do not choose to give my money to a company that has given me terrible customer service.

We have had an MBNA card for 15 years. I had a less than stellar interaction with their CS dept, called the manager and told them that I would pay the balance off, but that I would not cancel. I use their card but I never give them any interest. They keep offering me 0%, and I may take them up on it, but they won't get any interest, I will pay it off before the prometion runs out.
 
luvdzne said:
I don't don't totally agree on a company holding your funds for 7 days because you can reverse it.
If I read the messages correctly, the credit card company isn't holding any funds. It is simply not re-extending credit. What they're doing is prudent in a world filled with people looking to exploit every possible loophole for their own personal advantage -- we all suffer because companies have to guard themselves against such abuse by a few miscreants, because sometimes it is hard to tell us from them.

I paid the wrong company a huge amount on line and didn't notice it for a few days. When I called the bank they said there was nothing they could do. I would have to wait until the company sends me the overage.
There are laws governing how quickly credit card companies have to refund credit balances, after a request is made. It varies by state. I think here in MA it is 45 days. Of course, if you just let the bank follow their own procedures, as they suggested to you, it is likely that you'd get the refund much earlier than that, because they probably craft their procedures specifically to ensure that they automatically comply with the law.

I agree I would not base not using this card because of this policy, for me it would be..
1. The embarrassment from my card being denyed
2. The poor customer service
3. The poor customer service
4. I was hung up on
5. The way the employee spoke to me and refused to send me to a supervisor
6. Did I say poor customer service
I don't agree with #1, because that's not really the bank's fault. They have policies, spelled out (by law) in their terms and conditions. The fact that I didn't know, and didn't check to ensure I had enough credit available before trying to purchase something, is my fault, not theirs.

#2, #3 and #6 aren't clear-cut: It is very hard to gauge actuality from hearing only one side of the story. If there was that much bad customer service, then perhaps it would be a foundation for cancelling the credit card. However, even if there was that much bad customer service, it cannot be considered in a vacuum -- it needs to be stacked up against the bad customer service that you're likely to get from another bank (and the other down-sides of switching). You could be jumping from the frying pan right into the fire.
 
Feralpeg said:
So, the moral of this story is that you can carry a large balance and make small payments and still use your card. If you make a large payment, you are penalized.
I think it goes deeper than that. I suspect that each customer's individual credit history is factored in as well. I've often made big payments. I recently made a $6,000 payment on a credit card. I wasn't penalized for it at all. This is because, over time, I built up a history of running up big balances on the card and paying it off with a big payment.
 
bicker said:
If I read the messages correctly, the credit card company isn't holding any funds. It is simply not re-extending credit. What they're doing is prudent in a world filled with people looking to exploit every possible loophole for their own personal advantage -- we all suffer because companies have to guard themselves against such abuse by a few miscreants, because sometimes it is hard to tell us from them.

Maybe I wasn't clear, sorry it was early. :teeth: I was talking about the company receiving the payment but basically not posting it when the payment was actually received.

There are laws governing how quickly credit card companies have to refund credit balances, after a request is made. It varies by state. I think here in MA it is 45 days. Of course, if you just let the bank follow their own procedures, as they suggested to you, it is likely that you'd get the refund much earlier than that, because they probably craft their procedures specifically to ensure that they automatically comply with the law.

The bank did nothing but told me to wait for the company to send my check from the overpayment. They did not offer any other words of wisdom other than we're sorry. I would have gladly let them handle it.

I don't agree with #1, because that's not really the bank's fault. They have policies, spelled out (by law) in their terms and conditions. The fact that I didn't know, and didn't check to ensure I had enough credit available before trying to purchase something, is my fault, not theirs.

It may be in their policy, but there are plenty of companies that don't have that practice, so yes I would cancel them if this happened to me. I should not have to call to make sure my payment was applied in a timely manner when it clearly has cleared my bank. Also, I'm not talking about they have not received the payment yet so it hasn't posted to my account.

I am basing my facts on the op. The op asked what I would do.

2, #3 and #6 aren't clear-cut: It is very hard to gauge actuality from hearing only one side of the story. If there was that much bad customer service, then perhaps it would be a foundation for cancelling the credit card. However, even if there was that much bad customer service, it cannot be considered in a vacuum -- it needs to be stacked up against the bad customer service that you're likely to get from another bank (and the other down-sides of switching). You could be jumping from the frying pan right into the fire.
Again, I am basing my post on what the op said and asked. Yes, if I received customer service as described by the op I would and have canceled my card or service.

If you don't like the terms or customer service, yes it is worth checking out other companies. ;)
 
bicker said:
I think it goes deeper than that. I suspect that each customer's individual credit history is factored in as well. I've often made big payments. I recently made a $6,000 payment on a credit card. I wasn't penalized for it at all. This is because, over time, I built up a history of running up big balances on the card and paying it off with a big payment.

:thumbsup2 Or they wonder *why* you made a large payment. :rotfl2: I made a large one on my Disney account and within a couple weeks, I got a letter with "we noticed you recently made a large payment...we hope you aren't leaving...here are some great promo checks for you to use" type of thing.

Everything really boils down to even though there are laws, the credit card companies can do whatever they want, whenever they want to do it. A lot of times they will do something and as long as you don't complain, great, if you complain then they change things (my DH's interest rate was raised once, called to ask why -- and was prepared to balance transfer it since it was a crazy amount they raised it to. When he called he was told they raised it across the board & they only checked into lowering it if you called. His was lowered.) I know there are ones out there that charge you if you do the charge & pay off without paying interest. A whole host of other things. If you have good credit, you have the option of switching to different companies, etc...
 
Thank you all for your replies. I am much better today. I was so mad yesterday. I have worked very hard to establish good credit and this just floored me. Also, I never carry high balances and I had used this card for a vacation to Washington D.C./Connecticut. So when I returned and paid it off so quickly, this is how I was treated. It wasn't so much their "policies" of holding the funds, it was the way I was treated. My other credit card company tried to do the same thing when I sent a $1,300 payment. I called them after a few days and wondered why my available credit was -0-. They put me on hold and then came back and told me that they had reversed the hold and my funds were available. BECAUSE I was a good customer and they wanted my business. That is the card I will be using now. I will not use the other card. But, from what I understand, it's not a good practice to cancel cards. It looks better on your credit report to keep low or no balances which show even though you have the card, you don't use it. I will see how I feel after i hear back from them after they receive the letter I sent telling them my side and how I was treated. Credit or not, depending on their response, I might end up cancelling it anyways to make sure they know I won't be treated like that. There are too many companies out there that would want my business. Thanks again ya'll........... :sunny:
 
bicker said:
I think it goes deeper than that. I suspect that each customer's individual credit history is factored in as well. I've often made big payments. I recently made a $6,000 payment on a credit card. I wasn't penalized for it at all. This is because, over time, I built up a history of running up big balances on the card and paying it off with a big payment.

I guess that's possible, but I've had an account with Sears for 35 years. When I moved to Florida, I bought two refrigerators, two sets of washer/dryers and a big screen TV in one day (bought for myself and my sister). I paid it off the next day. I only charged it in the first place because I got a discount for using the card. That was on my regular Sears card (not Sears Mastercard). I have about as good a credit rating as a person can have. In fact, I never asked for the Sears Mastercard. It just showed up one day. So, I try to use it and have nothing but hassles. Instead of just releasing my credit line, the customer service guy wanted to increase my credit line. I didn't want more credit.

I understand that we all pay for the credit woes of others. I just don't need to deal with these types of hassles. I'm sure that Sears won't miss me.
 
luvdzne said:
Maybe I wasn't clear, sorry it was early. :teeth: I was talking about the company receiving the payment but basically not posting it when the payment was actually received.
Uh, okay, I'm confused. That was in reference to the OP's situation... :)

The bank did nothing but told me to wait for the company to send my check from the overpayment.
That doesn't matter. Your request in writing to them for refund would start the 45 day clock. It's explained in the credit card disclosure you got when you opened your account (or more recently if changed -- it might actually be explained on the back of your bill, too).

It may be in their policy, but there are plenty of companies that don't have that practice, so yes I would cancel them if this happened to me.
Okay, but remember that the next company might have other rules that you won't like, or might not have some of the benefits of the original bank that you do like. It sounds like this was an affinity card -- typically the better the benefits, the worse the rules.

I am basing my facts on the op. The op asked what I would do.
Yeah, bouncing back and forth from your own situation to the OP's situation is confusing. :confused:

Again, I am basing my post on what the op said and asked.
Understood. My comments were looking at a broader perspective than that.
 
Juniper is notorious for this. I have read about it on my credit boards.

Wells Fargo put a hold on our card because we paid more than the balance and they don't allow credit balances. :rolleyes:
 
If your credit limit is 900, why did you pay 916? (or whatever it was)

That happened to me. I paid my entire balance at the same time a credit was going through, so they put my account on hold.
 

New Posts

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom