We did
Free Dining last year. It saved the two of us about $150, we had mixed feelings about FD.
I did two 2 credit dinners because I had the credits to spend but typically would not eat two huge meals for dinner in a four night trip.
We typically eat light for breakfast, then snack/share for lunch and then dinner. In fact we typically either get two entrées or get one appetizer and one entrée and share. We really are more snackers than formal meals.
We don't tend to want desserts after meals. (sweet snacks okay but only like one a day, but not after a big meal).
We only refilled our mugs twice in 5 days.
we stayed at a mod and the type of room my mom wanted it made sense as the room only discount was still slightly more with the one expensive meal we had planned and all the F&W festival "snack credit" items we were going to buy. Only $150 but enough for us to use the package and kind of adapt it to our eating style.
This year we are not planning a Fantasmic Dinner Package, we will not be trying as many F&W snacks (we kind of know what we like so will only hit a few favorites and maybe try a couple new), I actually have an AP so I don't need a ticket and my mom is crushing on WL Courtyard view. (I do love my Mama, so right now WL is the hotel)
This year FD will probably not save us any money. With the way we normally eat and our plan to have only one higher priced meal (lunch at Brown Derby with other meals either CS or one or two lower tier TS like BOG where we only order what we actually will want or eat) and no need for mugs. I'm betting that a room only (either GP or AP Which should be around $300-$400 dollars) will be more then the amount of food we will pay OOP).
For us it's not a matter of "FREE" it's a matter of numbers. Any deal can be better IF the parameters of the deal fit your style, level or use of the discount itself.
I will run the numbers for both and make final decisions then. This is IF Free Dining is offered for our dates in Oct.