They have Happily Ever After, you could also have them write your anniversary on that. They should have one behind the register at most stores and at restaurants too. You don't have to go to City Hall.
We were there two weeks ago for the Anniversary of our Engagement. At the main gate / turn-styles the CM asked about our visit and we told her. She had a small zip lock bag with pins. We both got one and wore them all day. Many CM's congratulated us.
I'm sure you can get them! I hope this is what you are referring to?
When we checked into the DLH, the cast member asked if we were celebrating anything. When we told her it was our anniversary, he gave us the buttons, and signed Mickey picture. Some of the people in the shops also have the buttons.
yes! we got ours when we went in September and were pixie dusted by another couple when they saw them, they gave us 12 use anywhere fastpasses and told us happy anniversary
We will be there a week after our anniversary...that counts right?? LOL We actually aren't doing anything for our anniversary because of that. But we will be stopping there on the first day for my son to get his first visit pin!