Perhaps, but it still leads me to the last part of my statement:
Shoppers are going to shop and non-shoppers won't (no matter how much time you give them).
Believe, me I am not naive enough to think that the sole reason they are doing this is to for people just to shop more. I am sure it added into the equation. But I would hate for them to be naive enough to think that everyone automatically will shop more/spend more just because they have more time.
For us, we will take the extra time and simply head back to the resort and spend time at the pool (and thus spend nothing additional) since I will not spend my afternoons in 60 minute + standby lines once my 3 FP's are gone.
Limit it as much as it is feared it will be someday, and we will take all our "extra" time as well as our vacation $$$ to a completely different destination.
Just my 2 cents, YMMV
I agree with this: Non-shoppers are not going to shop (no matter how much time you give them).
But I don't completely agree with this: Shoppers are going to shop (no matter how much time you give them).
I woud say: Shoppers are going to shop more if you give them more time.
I know many kids don't like to shop, but don't think for a minute that it applies to all kids. Some kids LOVE to shop! Mine will try to drag me into a shop any chance they get, and they've been to a Disney park at least once a year since 2007. I've learned to limit them to a fixed amount of spending money per visit. But first-timers...?
I also am not talking just the purchase of suveniers from gift shops. I'm talking about things like this:
Before: "It's really hot, let's ride splash mountain. Oh, but the line is an hour long. Well, let's grab a quick bite at Pecos Bill first and try again after lunch."
After: "It's really hot, but our FP+ for Splash Mountain isn't until 2pm. Let's take our time in an air conditioned restaurant and buy a big lunch while we wait."
I don't know, maybe I'm missing the mark with this idea. But my family and I thought we were pretty savvy FP users. That is until our last trip when they started enforcing the return time windows. Now we would often found ourselves either sprinting across the park to try to make the next FP time, or trying to find something to do for 15 minutes while we waited for that return time. That was the perfect time to slow down and grab an ice cream, or a churro, or a popcorn (ie. spend more money). I see this happening A LOT for first-timers who are trying to figure out how to not miss their next FP+ return time.
Remember, Disney spent a lot of money on this system. I'm sure this isn't the only way they will increase revenue by this change, but I gotta think it's part of it.
*** Spoiler Alert *** a little doom and gloom ahead ***
Unless there's still something we're missing (and there very well could be), Disney had to know that WDW veterans who have spent years perfecting their FP maximization strategies were going to HATE this FP+ idea. But I think they view that demographic as such a small part of their revenue stream, that they are willing to lose some good will there, and maybe completely lose a few loyal fans altogether. But you know what? There will be thousands more to replace us, as new parents start bringing their kids - parents who never knew there was an old version of FP. And they're going to LOVE FP+ (maybe because of marketing as much as anything else), and they're going to be the new die-hard fans who want to keep coming back.
Sorry, I'll stop talking about this now. Just my little opinion on something that we still know very little (officially) about.