Hi!
I only ever did this one time. On our May, 2003 trip we were going through the turnstiles at Epcot. You know, the hectic part where the bag check & ticket turnstiles are right on top of each other (I PRAY that this has changed and that there is more room between each now!! LOL). Anyway we're going through & 4yo ds says, "Look, Mom, my tooth is loose!!" We looked down to see him holding it in his hand!! I never even knew that he had any loose teeth!!
Being the fact that it was his FIRST lost tooth & the creative, frugal mom that I am - everywhere we went I would sneak away to CM's at each venue & explain what happened & asked if there was anything that "The Toothfairy & Tinkerbell" (she's a fairy, too, right! LOL) could give to leave under his pillow for him. His older brothers loved helping out on it, too.
He received a certificate from Tinkerbell & The Tooth Fairy, a little Mickey Soccer Ball, a Test Track pin, Pooh magnet from England,
Disneyland Paris Magnet from Fance, chocolate from Italy, a dreamcatcher from Canada, jewels from Morocco & his favorite, a Toothfairy Finger Puppet from Germany & a few other things that I can't remember.
He awoke & was disappointed that there was nothing under his pillow (I think the one thing that was under it fell off during the night). His brothers pointed to the bedside table & found notes from The Tooth Fairy & Tinkerbell with all of the gifts (he was also disappointed that they weren't wrapped!! LOL)
All of these were free gifts from WDW. We've been there numerous times & have found that Disney is very accomodating during special times like this one.
I would have never gone to the extremes with this, but you only loose your first tooth one time, right? LOL
This year "Tinkerbell" is going to leave a different collector pin in our room each night!!
Have fun playing "Tinkerbell"!!

Deb