I went on POTC the night of the 12th and DH and I had the pleasure of sitting at the front. I had heard of people complain about the water, so I was bracing myself (not because I mind getting wet, but because its darn cold in there!). Because the ride had just reopened a few minutes earlier the boat arrived dry as a bone. However, when we went down the hill, our legs got pretty wet. Not soaked, but wet enough that I was cold and shivering for the rest of the ride. But all in all, I like the refurb and the new boats. Honestly, it fits the themeing to get a little wet.
P.S. I think the water in ANY water based ride in Disney is disgusting, so I don't see the how getting wet on POTC is any different from getting wet on Splash Mountain. You are not swimming in it. That just my humble opinion. As long as I am not wading through the water, I am fine.