DS8 will be making his first communion in a couple of weeks. We did have a choice to either do it during a mass or with the group of his CCD class. We chose to have him do it with his friends rather than the entire congrigation.
By making that choice, we agreed that we'd only be able to have 11 people at the church. Here's how we tried to split them out --
3 seats = DH, DS8 and I will be seated in a separate section of the church from our guests.
no seat = our DS3 will be left with a friend.
2 seats = my mom and caregiver (my mom is handicapped).
2 seats = My MIL and BIL will be there -- BIL is an adult, however, he has down syndrome
2 seats = Godmother and SO
2 seats = Godfather, his wife and 2 children (5 years old)
Did you notice that last line -- actually 4 people for 2 seats?? It left us in a really awkward position to invite DS's Godfather but tell him he couldn't bring his children (who are 5). His Godfather & wife decided that DS's Godfather would attend while his wife and children stayed at our house. Then Godfather's wife had a conflict and is required to take a class the day of DS8's communion so that left Godfather with the 2 kids and himself alone for the day

eek: they would need 3 seats!!). Although DS's Godfather would like to be there, he decided that he just couldn't do it because of the seating.
No matter how we tried, we couldn't make it work to include DS's Godfather and his family. But, we talked to them about it and tried to work out a solution. It was a nightmare and really awkward to be in that position.
So, sometimes, it's really not something that can be worked out because of other restrictions but it would have been nice if some type of option would have been mentioned to your DH.
We also decided rather than do a Communion party right away, we're going to wait until we're a little more confident in the weather and put one of those jumping things in the yard and have a party here. That way, we can invite more than 11 people!!
