We have eaten there twice for dinner - before it went back to 2 credits for dinner.
We had one phenomenal experience, and once so-so experience.
The 2nd time was the so-so experience - we had to wait over an hour for our ADR - it was awful. They really need to add more benches outside the restaurant.
The reservation was late to start with - around 8:30 I think - so we didn't get in till around 9:30 - by the time we had desert it was going almost 10:45 pm due to the fact that I had to sent my too tough to even cut steak back. I had ordered the coffee rubbed steak, and while the flavor of the first few bites was amazing - I couldn't even cut it after the first few bites. There were three veins of gristle running right through the center of the cut.
They brought me an new steak - I told him I would take what they could bring the quickest, I think it was the NY Strip - that was delicious - but 15-20 minutes late - it was insanely late.
I'm sure we will eat there again - perhaps we will have better luck with on-time ADR seating by going for lunch.
The steaks are fantastic - however, they aren't as good as what we had on our honeymoon in 2006 at the Concourse Steakhouse at the Contemporary. unfortunately - the Concourse is no longer there
We have also had amazing steaks at Coral Reef - we took my parents in 2008 and my mom was still talking about how that was the most amazing steak she had ever eaten!
We have yet to try the Yachtsman - but I hear it is superb as well.
I have also heard great things about the Turf club at Saratoga Springs.