Welcome, MyLove4Disney and thanks for the tips. I have looked at the others on the boards, but it's nice to get them directly & for adults. Being childless, we do come at it from a different perspective, and we are planning on taking advantage of the adult evening entertainment.
I hear you about the shoes, but we're only bringing
crocs & dance shoes (which will double for evening shoes). As far as overpacking goes though, it's 7 days, you need day clothes & evening clothes. I know I can manage on a couple of evening outfits, but surely in the Caribean you can't wear the day's clothes more than one day? And as you said, it's vacation, I don't want to do laundry! So how much is overpacking?