I can't tell you about the time of year you are going, but I have 2 kids ages 10 and 12.
Our first visit to the world (may 06) we did:
Liberty Tree Tavern; This is a charcter dinner, and hands down, my kids favorite! The food is pretty good, and there is lots of character interaction.
Coral Reef: We all really disliked this restaurant. Thought we would love it because most of us love seafood. I found it to be overpriced, noisy and the food not very good at all. However, if your kids like seafood, and are big aqurium lovers, then give this a try. Most people really like it.
Crystal Palace: We did the character breakfast here. The food was buffet style, and it was average. Not bad, just not great. The character interaction here was slow, so slow that the CM gave us each a free Fast Pass for the wait. It took us almost 2 hours to see the characters, and we ended up leaving before Winnie the Pooh made it over. The price was good though.
Prime Time: This was the runner up for the kids fave! It's good food, and great cast member interaction.
The rest of our meals were counter service (peco bills, pizzafari) and the rest eaten outside the parks.
This June we are staying onsite, so we're doing the
DDP. I have ADR's at these restaurants (this is a surprise trip...kids have no idea!)
Le Cellier
Whispering Canyon Cafe
Hoop De Doo
Alfredo's
Chefs de France (my DD 12 has always wanted to try escargot!)
Hollywood/Vine (fantasmic dinner package)
Liberty tree tavern
Crystal Palace (yup, gonna give it another try..this time for dinner)
It's a good combo of nice and fun.