I'm honestly not sure if I would. Our daughter was teething the entire time and was in a miserable mood, but of course that had nothing to do with Disney. It did make it a bit stressful though. Thing is we did enjoy our cruise prior to what we now refer to as the
Castaway Cay Catastrophe

We liked cruising better than the resorts we visited in the past. Would we go with Disney again - not sure. The kids did love it but I was so unimpressed with how they handled the last couple of days.
We tried to make calls the night we got stranded and were told not to come down 'til the next morning at 9 am. I later found out other people were making calls that night. I have to wonder of Disney wanted to rebook THEIR passengers first... I don't know but it really messed us up as we entirely missed our flight by the time we were able to make a call almost SIX hours after waiting in line without Disney so much as passing out water despite a few people specificall asking CM's to do so. They were also offering to compensate certain people who had to
trip insurance and not others. Then, when we ultimately got to the airport, Continental apparently never confirmed our flight on Air Canada (which I do not buy - they were overbooked because other passengers were irate) and we got bumped from a direct at noon to a layover flight at 5pm - not fun with a tween throwing up every hours. Finally, we had to book a hotel in Montreal because we got in so late and THEY lost our ressies too. I kid you not. Overall, a disaster. Now I recognize that isn't ALL Disney's fault, but it doesn't leave you with a warm, fuzzy feeling at the end of your vacation!

We also saw a line of passengers that Disney had apparently rebooked that found out at the airport they had no flight home. Don't even get me started on the disaster at the port for debarkation.
Putting all that aside, as I said we did enjoy cruising in general. If things had been better we probably would go with them again. Who knows, maybe once the irritation wears off, we will be able to chalk it up to a one off - I know this is the exception rather than the norm. The food was great and most of the staff was fantastic.
The only downside (pre CCC

) was we both agreed we would have preferred longer to explore the islands.. ie. 2 days in any given port which Disney doesn't offer yet. Maybe we'll try a different line and the experience will leave us thinking our Disney experience with the CCC and all was a walk in the park!
