We have many "nice" favorites, but Artist Point is by far at the top of the list.
We've eaten at about 3/4 of the restaurants (table service), and are anxious to try Victoria and Alberts yet to see if that might top it. But so far Artist Point is heads and tails above the rest.
For us its Artist Point and Yachtsman tied for first. Jiko, Bistro de Paris, Flying Fish & Narcoossee's thereafter.
No, V&A isn't on our list simply for price reasons. We don't mind paying at upscale restaurants, but this is a bit out of our league for normal dining. Yes, we have done it and it was certainly a fantastic experience. Just not in the cards for our usual routine.
I can't pick just one! I was fortunate to live a few hours from WDW so I've eaten at a good many of them. I really love the Flying Fish for food and ambience and Fultons for their crab legs. They have the freshest seafood!
Teppanyaki must have been good because we ate there more than any other restaurant! Will definitely be trying the new joints over there.
FlameTree BBQ at AK had really great sandwiches and ribs -- and we are a little snobby when it comes to our BBQ!
And not to sound like a broken record, but we really loved our last meal at Le Cellier.