I just got back this week, and out of all the restaurants we tried, the Yachtman's Steakhouse was by far our favorite for food and service, followed closely by Narcoossee's.
Le Cellier, but there are still tons of restaurants that I haven't tried and I have been over 10 times. There are so many at the resorts that I haven't tried. I am looking forward to several during our next trip.
California Grill. We loved the sophisticated atmoshphere, the innovative menu and the attentive service. I love the themed restaurants but this was a nice departure. Very modern and sleek. And we had the added bonus of being there during Wishes. This is the only restaurant we're repeating on next year's trip.
Boma, Kona Cafe & Le Cellier. They're all different but the only places we'll return to on our next trip since there's other places we still need to try.