So hard for me to choose! We really like everywhere we have stayed for different reasons.
Aulani definitely wins my “not at WDW” vote and possibly the overall vote. Our grand villa was stunning.
VGF is my winner for at WDW. Light and bright. Location is great for us in this phase of life (with toddlers we spend a ton of time at MK.)
Poly bungalow was awesome. But it is a little dark and it is small for the number of points. Happy we did it but probably would not do it again.
We have enjoyed everywhere else we have stayed (SSR, Grand Californian, BLT, AKV-Kidani, Vero Beach). My issues with Kidani and Grand Californian are that our villas there were so dark. I really like light and bright in the morning!