we've eaten just about everywhere and more that once too, so here's my favorites:
in Magic Kingdom: Crystal Palace breakfast.. puffed french toast and ambiance
recent first time at Tony's and loved it. For counter service it's Cosmic Ray's b/c of the toppings bar but can be very crowded!
in Epcot: We love Tutto, every meal was awesome, especially the eggplant parmesean appetizer mmmm... but our recent first time was at Teppan Edo and we really liked that. For counter service all the pics of Sunshine Seasons made me drool but after actually going there last time i was unimpressed. long waits for food that wasnt ready, no beef and broccoli and the shortcake was too full of just whipped cream taste.. so my counter service goes to Mexico's stand, the combo was great.
in Animal Kingdom: Yak and Yeti is our favorite, and so is breakfast at Tusker House b/c of the cheese blintzes! For counter it is Flame Tree.. love the ribs and corn muffin-and eating outside with the ducks.
DHS: 50's is our favorite b/c of the meatloaf and peanut butter and jelly shake! 2nd would be sci-fi but we've had terrible service twice. For counter, we dont have a favorite b/c we've only had pizza planet once, which was ok.
Resorts!! Here's our MOST favorite TS... Ohana for sure, dinner of course. Next is Kona for dinner.. greatest bread and macadamia nut butter. Oh and sticky wings and teryaki steak, i must do this on every trip! Can't wait!! 1900 Park Fare for lobster eggs benedict and ambiance.