I think it all comes down to a personal preference.
I'm type-A, OCD and like to be in control. I prefer to wait at the baggage claim area, get my bags, and rent a car.
I've used Magical Express only once, and it just wasn't for me. We arrived late in the evening - probably 9pm - 10pm, with a tired, hungry 17 month old. We were cruising, and I didn't want to risk a problem with the airline, DME or the resort misplacing our bags when we had to leave the resort early the next morning. So I got our luggage. I will say that it was a breeze to check in and we walked right onto a bus. We then had to sit on the bus and wait a designated period of time to try and fill the bus. I'm SURE this was a result of our late arrival, and the need to get as many people on the bus as possible - but it's little unknowns like that that make me not want to use DME. And that's truly a personal preference. I think DME is absolutely as efficient as it possibly can be, and I have no gripes about it. It really just doesn't work for me.
I've also used a car service, only once. Had a FANTASTIC experience. But it leaves me without a car on property.
In the end, I really much prefer to drive myself to the parks. To me, it truly is part of the fun. I completely understand and respect people who feel differently and prefer to ride the busses.
If I didn't care about that, I wouldn't hesitate to use the Magical Express. And like goofy4tink, if I had a little
budget cushion, I'd spring for a town car.
