Our family is going to Disney in October also, and I debating the same thing!! We live in Indianapolis area, and fares are around $200 also. AirTran has not released fares yet for October, and that is who we flew on last time. We only paid about $187 total(taxes and all) with Airtran, and they have TONS of flights to Orlando every day from here. I think I may hold out to see what AirTran is offering!