Fantasmic VS Dine With An Imagineer

[SDGal]

I scoured the googlesphere and couldn't really find a good discussion about this. So here's my question for Disney lifers.

Last time we went to WDW, we got a Fantasmic dining package at HBD and we're a little offput by the early time. We really loved the premium seating for the show though. We are also very into the idea of Dine with an Imagineer. We are only doing one day in DHS, so it's going to come down to one or the other. I'd like the opinion of someone who has done both and has a preference. I'd appreciate any ideas or info. Thanks!

 

[ConnecticutNonna]

I scoured the googlesphere and couldn't really find a good discussion about this. So here's my question for Disney lifers.

Last time we went to WDW, we got a Fantasmic dining package at HBD and we're a little offput by the early time. We really loved the premium seating for the show though. We are also very into the idea of Dine with an Imagineer. We are only doing one day in DHS, so it's going to come down to one or the other. I'd like the opinion of someone who has done both and has a preference. I'd appreciate any ideas or info. Thanks!

Since you have alreafy scored on the F+ front, I'd ay lunch with an Imagineer!
Each trip we try to do something different (a tour, fw cruise, etc)... Next trip (after this one) will be lunch with an Imagineer!

 

[HopperFan]

Hands down Dining with Imagineer ..... if you can even get an ADR. One of the toughest to get.

 

[Meriweather]

Lunch with an Imagineer.......for sure!! Love, love it. Been 5 times and have another next week

 

[focusondisney]

Very excited- just booked Lunch with an Imagineer this morning for our May trip. Never been before, so glad to hear all the positive comments!!