We went down at Spring Break one year and made the Fantasmic dinner reservations. We told the CM on phone that we wanted our passes to the 2nd showing of Fantastmic. She said fine. We got to the Brown Derby and were told there were no passes for the second show, only the first. We would get passes to the first show. This messed up our planned day (fast passes, etc). The Brown Derby was very understanding, but couldn't do anything for the second show. We took the passes for the first show and rearranged our day. Just wanted to warn anyone who might try this. We were told the second showing is not hard to get into.