Error on a pin purchased at Disney's Soda Fountain

[Etoile]

I purchased two copies of PinPics #59107 today. I bought them at the Disney Soda Fountain on Hollywood Blvd today when we went to see the Chinese Theater. One of them is exactly the same as on the PinPics website, and in the other, the "Y" in HAPPY is not filled in. The gold outline is there but the color inside it is not.

I bought both the error and the regular because I wasn't sure if I'd stumbled on something or not. I bought this at the official DSF location, so I know it is a real pin sold to me by Disney. I have the receipt and everything. (I bought a few other pins there too.)

I am brand new to pin trading and I don't know what to do in a situation like this. Is it considered a "different" or "error" pin because of the mistake? Is it worth any more or less than the normal one I got? I worry that if I offer it to trade, somebody won't want it because it has an error.

What do I do? Thanks in advance!

 

[I'mNoPrince]

With the thousands of Official Pins pumped out now I'm sure some slide by QC .

As for if it's worth any more you just never know but that defect doesn't sound enough to be.

Tradable Yes as who would really know as long as the Info on the back is legit.

 

[actionvaughn]

I would suggest trying to get it changed back at the Soda Fountain. Like the poster above mentioned, it is tradable, but I'm sure there aren't any traders out there that will want a defective pin in their collections.

 

[Etoile]

Exchanging it is not an option because we flew back home to Washington DC today! Perhaps my best bet is to hold onto it until my in-laws go to WDW in April, and ask them to trade it with a CM.