While Cape May is a nice character meal, if you're looking for some delicious food, one of Disney's "hidden secrets" is Yacht Club Galley. They serve a buffet plus off the menu choices and the food is excellent. Atmosphere is very nice, usually not crowded and service also excellent. The buffet is not huge like Chef Mickey, but definetely adequate.
We've tried Spoodles for breakfast and didn't care for it, many people like it, maybe we ordered the wrong thing.
We've also tried Fresh. This is a nice buffet, but it's been a while since we've eaten there and I've heard it's changed some. They make your eggs, etc, right in front of you while you stand there and also have fresh juices, (some wacky combos), and nice breads, muffins etc. We're eating there again in October since my sister's friend wants to try it.
Cape May has good food too.
Our personal choice of all would be Yacht Club Galley.