either or??

[deslynnpatterson]

would you pick...

Liberty Tree or garden grill?
Plaza or Crystal Palace?
Tonys of Mama Melrose?
Teppan Edo or Biergarden?
Ohana or Kona?
grand Floridian cafe or 1900 Park Fair?
The wave or chef mickeys?
yak and yeti or tusker house?

just for fun

 

[jodywgirl]

would you pick...

Liberty Tree or garden grill? Liberty Tree
Plaza or Crystal Palace? Crystal Palace
Tonys of Mama Melrose? Mama Melrose
Teppan Edo or Biergarden? Teppan Edo
Ohana or Kona? Ohana
grand Floridian cafe or 1900 Park Fair? Grand Floridian Cafe
The wave or chef mickeys? Chef Mickeys
yak and yeti or tusker house? Yak & Yeti

just for fun

I haven't been to a few of these and I'm going with what everyone else says

 

[SuzieN]

Liberty Tree or garden grill? Liberty Tree Tavern - especially for lunch
Plaza or Crystal Palace? love both, but probably Crystal Palace
Tonys of Mama Melrose? Tony's (but never ate at Mama's)
Teppan Edo or Biergarden? Biergarten - lot's of fun and GREAT atmosphere
Ohana or Kona? Kona - 'Ohana was YUCK! (dry dry dry meats)
grand Floridian cafe or 1900 Park Fair? haven't been to either
The wave or chef mickeys? haven't been to either but I hear great things about The Wave
yak and yeti or tusker house? Yak & Yeti!!! one of my favorite WDW restaurants

 

[Cat0727]

Liberty Tree or garden grill? Liberty Tavern
Plaza or Crystal Palace? Crystal Palace
Tonys of Mama Melrose? Mama Melrose
Teppan Edo or Biergarden? (havent been yet, but I'll say the one I want to try first) Teppan Edo
Ohana or Kona? Kona
grand Floridian cafe or 1900 Park Fair? 1900 park Fair
The wave or chef mickeys? The Wave
yak and yeti or tusker house? Tusker House

 

[honeydiane1953]

would you pick...

Liberty Tree or garden grill?
Plaza or Crystal Palace?
Tonys of Mama Melrose?
Teppan Edo or Biergarden?
Ohana or Kona?
grand Floridian cafe or 1900 Park Fair?
The wave or chef mickeys?
yak and yeti or tusker house?

just for fun

Every choice but I would choose THE WAVE. The food is excellent there.

 

[MarinaD]

Liberty Tree
Crystal Palace?
Tonys
Teppan Edo
1900 Park Fair?
chef mickeys
tusker house?

Just my opinion!

 

[stephmarty]

would you pick...

Liberty Tree or garden grill?
Plaza or Crystal Palace?
Tonys of Mama Melrose?
Teppan Edo or Biergarden?
Ohana or Kona?
grand Floridian cafe or 1900 Park Fair?
The wave or chef mickeys?
yak and yeti or tusker house?

just for fun

Liberty Tree, Crystal Palace, Tony's, Teppan Edo, Grand Floridian Cafe, Chef Mickey's, Tusker House. Gotta have 'Ohana and Kona. Keep in mind I haven't eaten at all of these places yet, but this is how I've booked my ADRs based on what I know so far.

 

[belleatheart]

would you pick...

Liberty Tree or garden grill? Garden Grill
Plaza or Crystal Palace?Crystal Palace
Tonys of Mama Melrose?Ummmm neither if choosing tony's
Teppan Edo or Biergarden?Teppan Edo, love sushi
Ohana or Kona?KONA!!!!
grand Floridian cafe or 1900 Park Fair?Grand Floridian
The wave or chef mickeys?Well i love chef mickey's for characters but the wave for food
yak and yeti or tusker house?Yak and Yeti

just for fun

Hahaha it is also hard because i just love food

 

[dacky041208]

would you pick...

Liberty Tree or garden grill?
Plaza or Crystal Palace?
Tonys of Mama Melrose?
Teppan Edo or Biergarden?
Ohana or Kona?
grand Floridian cafe or 1900 Park Fair?
The wave or chef mickeys?
yak and yeti or tusker house?

just for fun

answers in bold

 

[Ms.Mouse]

Liberty Tree
Crystal Palace
Mama Melrose
Teppan Edo
Kona
grand Floridian cafe
The wave
yak and yeti

 

[JerseyJanice]

I like Dacky's bolding idea.

Liberty Tree or garden grill? Neither
Plaza or Crystal Palace?
Tonys of Mama Melrose?
Teppan Edo or Biergarden?
Ohana or Kona?
grand Floridian cafe or 1900 Park Fair? Dinner-GFC / breakfast-1900 PF.
The wave or chef mickeys? With kids-Chef M's / adults only-The Wave.
yak and yeti or tusker house? Breakfast-TH / lunch or dinner-Y&Y.

 

[bangzoom6877]

would you pick...

Liberty Tree or garden grill?
Plaza or Crystal Palace?
Tonys of Mama Melrose?
Teppan Edo or Biergarden?
Ohana or Kona?
grand Floridian cafe or 1900 Park Fair?
The wave or chef mickeys?
yak and yeti or tusker house?

just for fun

1. Garden Grill (would only go for dinner and I have little ones, so I would pick this based on characters...LTT dinner was good but they had characters last time we went)

2. Crystal Palace (again, I have little ones and they love character meals...also the dinner food there was very good)

3. Neither Tony's nor Mama Melrose. Never been to either, but I generally don't get Italian food on vacation (Brooklyn Italian here)

4. Biergarten (we have hibachi restaurants here we take the kids to all the time, we love Biergarten and LOVE LOVE LOVE German food)

5. Kona (never been to either, but Kona's dinner menu is more appealing to us...going there for dinner on our July trip)

6. For breakfast, 1900 Park Fare (characters and I hear it is a great buffet...we have an ADR there for July). For dinner, Grand Floridian Cafe. Didn't care too much for the dinner food at 1900 park Fare, especially DH (I was ok with it, but it wasn't my favorite)

7. Chef Mickey's (the kids love it there! Been there for breakfast and loved it, but trying dinner in July. Still would try The Wave though, just not going on this trip)

8. Tusker House (for character breakfast...but we're not returning to AK this trip)

 

[tinkerdee]

would you pick...

Liberty Tree or garden grill? Liberty Tree
Plaza or Crystal Palace? Crystal Palace
Tonys of Mama Melrose? Tonys
Teppan Edo or Biergarden? Biergarden
Ohana or Kona?
grand Floridian cafe or 1900 Park Fair? 1900 Park Fair
The wave or chef mickeys? Chef Mickeys
yak and yeti or tusker house? Tusker House

just for fun

The main difference between all of those is a buffet or not, characters or not.
That is a personal decision, we like the buffets for the variety for our family. Either way, you can'y go wrong!!

 

[chocolateMinnie]

would you pick...

Liberty Tree or garden grill?
Plaza or Crystal Palace?(a million times Crystal palace)
Tonys of Mama Melrose? Never been to either
Teppan Edo or Biergarden? Only been to Biergarten, liked but not loved it.
Ohana or Kona? Ohana loved both meals preferred breakfast
grand Floridian cafe or 1900 Park Fair? Found GF cafe average 1920 pf appalling
The wave or chef mickeys? Never been to CM
yak and yeti or tusker house? Never been to either.

just for fun

great idea for a thread

 

[Wild4Walt]

would you pick...

Liberty Tree or garden grill? - Garden Grill - food was better and check in was less chaotic.

Plaza or Crystal Palace? have not done either of these

Tonys of Mama Melrose? tough choice - both are very good - Tony's has more variety, but I'd say the food was equally good at both

Teppan Edo or Biergarden? another toughie - Teppan Edo - great food and a must do every time we go!

Ohana or Kona? depends on if we are talking breakfast or dinner - breakfast - Kona hands down. Food is fresh and lots of variety. Got runny eggs and bacon at Ohana breakfast. Dinner - Ohana's - love the brazillian style.

grand Floridian cafe or 1900 Park Fair? Grand Fl Cafe - not into the buffett thing so much.

The wave or chef mickeys? The Wave because I've never tried it.

yak and yeti or tusker house? yak and yeti - food is fresh, the decor is really cool and the service has always been great!

just for fun

Liberty Tree or garden grill? - Garden Grill - food was better and check in was less chaotic.

Plaza or Crystal Palace? have not done either of these

Tonys of Mama Melrose? tough choice - both are very good - Tony's has more variety, but I'd say the food was equally good at both

Teppan Edo or Biergarden? another toughie - Teppan Edo - great food and a must do every time we go!

Ohana or Kona? depends on if we are talking breakfast or dinner - breakfast - Kona hands down. Food is fresh and lots of variety. Got runny eggs and bacon at Ohana breakfast. Dinner - Ohana's - love the brazillian style.

grand Floridian cafe or 1900 Park Fair? Grand Fl Cafe - not into the buffett thing so much.

The wave or chef mickeys? The Wave because I've never tried it.

yak and yeti or tusker house? yak and yeti - food is fresh, the decor is really cool and the service has always been great!

 

[MYD714]

would you pick...

Liberty Tree or garden grill?
Plaza or Crystal Palace?
Tonys of Mama Melrose?
Teppan Edo or Biergarden?
Ohana or Kona?
grand Floridian cafe or 1900 Park Fair?
The wave or chef mickeys?
yak and yeti or tusker house?

just for fun

Liberty Tree
Crystal Palace
Tony's
Teppan Edo--never ate here, but HATE Biergarten
Ohana
Either GFC or 1900 PF--never tried either of them
Chef Mickey's
Yak and Yeti--because I've never tried it

 

[Dsny4fun]

would you pick...

Liberty Tree or garden grill?
Plaza or Crystal Palace?
Tonys of ]B]Mama Melrose[/
Teppan Edoor BiergardenB]?
Ohana or Kona?
grand Floridian cafe or 1900 Park Fair?
The wave or chef mickeys?
yak and yeti or tusker house?

just for fun

Answers are bolded