I'm not so sure if enjoying the Values is the same as letting in a little bit of magic. I love to let the magic in, but I've always thought the Value's were garish. I'll be able to give you a more informed opinion after I stay at the Pop in April (something I said I'd never do, but financial reality is, well, reality).
I don't begrudge Disney for what they charge for any of their rooms - its all about supply and demand - its the American way. But as far as the Values go - if you're gonna build a cheap motel, why not just go ahead and do it. Dressing it up and calling it a resort doesn't fool anybody.