Thanks for doing the math for me on this one - I haven't gotten into the nitty gritty of it yet but would definitely need to do the math for each resort we hope to stay at and the different options for each. There will be four adults in our party, no children. I think I remember also seeing that there are some really good hotel rates available for the WL in Sept - someone posted about getting a room for $190/night through some magical something or other - sorry, can't remember off hand! Maybe it wasn't through Disney and wouldn't qualify for free dining. I thought that Disney did offer some good room discounts in the fall. Would it be an either or situation - either the room discount or free dining but not both?