I will admit I have read threads on this before and I am shocked and frightened at what I am reading in this thread. I just have a few comments-
1) Any poster who made a comment about those people who stay at value resorts and meant it as a cheap shot at them - Grow up! Everyone has the right to enjoy Disney anyway they see fit and how they can afford to do it.
2) Those of you who stay at the value resorts and misunderstood some of the posts, please learn how to read. I have seen comments from the people who stay at the value resorts who are upset at posts where people used the value resorts as an example of how the perk is being abused, not to take a cheap shot at you. I don't think there were many posts where poster meant that the people who stay at the value resorts are any less important than they are. They are just upset that some people do not follow the rules, and it impacts their enjoyment and vacation that they paid good money for. The people who abuse the rules do come from the value resorts as well as off property and other resorts that do not cost as much as the
DVC resorts.
3) Pool hopping is a feature that I enjoy (with my family) at DVC and non DVC resorts, and we do it because we are entitled to. Not because we are better than everyone else, we paid for that right and it is granted to us by DVC and WDW. If you are offended by that, too bad. I personally paid almost $40,000 plus about $2500 annually for dues and I feel that since I am allowed to pool hop that is great. If they took that away I would be very disappointed, but I would follow the rules and not pool hop.
4) Those of you who are reading these posts and pool hop when and where you are not supposed to listen up - I personally think that if you are caught you should be removed from the property immediately, escorted by several cast members for all to see. The rules should be explained to you so you have a full understanding of them and warned what will happen if you do it again. If you are caught a second time, you should be escorted from Walt Disney World. If you are staying on property, you should be forced to check out and not allowed to stay on Disney property for the duration of your vacation. You need to find accomodations somewhere else and Disney should not be obligated to help you. You have violated the rules and that impacts others enjoyment of their vacation. That may sound harsh to some, but there are posted signs and the people who do this know that they should not be.
5) They can't possibly enforce this rule with cast members, and they know it. They are negligent in protecting DVC members rights and we should let them know we are not satisfied, whether you do it while you are there and see it (ask to speak to the resort manager, don't just tell a cast member) or you send a letter, e-mail or make a phone call. Do not be rude, just tell them that it is an issue and you are unhappy. If you ask for a manager they will find one and you will be taking them from other tasks, this will get back to the people in charge and they will do something, although it will take time effort and energy on our part. Do not be passive, take an active role in protecting your vacation home. Do not just gripe about it here, do something about it.
6) It seems to me that the only feasible solution is to gate in the pools at the DVC resorts. If they wish to do it at the other resorts (which they should BTW) great, if not then the people staying there should complain. Our DVC dues pay for the operation of the resorts including the pools and the cost of installing and maintaining a gate system would be somewhat offset by the reduced wear and tear on the property, reduced chemical usage for the pool, less staff to patrol the pool and probably so slight an increase in dues that it would maybe cost each member pennies annually to operate. This seems to be a no brainer but they will not do it if no one complains about it.
I hope no one was offended by this post and if you were I am sorry that you did not like my comments. If you understood them and disagreed, great, but they were not meant to offend anyone. I just can't believe the sniping at each other that I read in this post and I hope that reason will take over.